Image Source: MyFitnessPal Blog
Prebiotic sodas have become a ubiquitous presence in top grocery stores, emerging as a popular choice among health-conscious consumers. Sparkling and enticing, these drinks are poised to be among the most sought-after beverages of 2025.
Why Prebiotic Sodas Are Trending
Prebiotic sodas are gaining traction as a healthier alternative to traditional sodas, which are often laden with added sugars. Excessive consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages, like soda, has been linked to various health concerns (CDC).
Many people are turning to prebiotic sodas because they contain less sugar, fewer calories, and are infused with gut-friendly ingredients. But are they truly a better option? We consulted a dietitian and reviewed the latest research to find out.
What Makes a Soda Prebiotic?
Prebiotic sodas are carbonated drinks designed to mimic regular sodas but with added prebiotics. Prebiotics are indigestible fibers that serve as food for beneficial gut bacteria, helping them thrive and flourish (Mayo Clinic).
Some prebiotic sodas also include probiotics—live microorganisms like bacteria and yeast. Prebiotics and probiotics often coexist in fiber-rich foods such as fruits, vegetables, whole grains, beans, legumes, yogurt, and sauerkraut.
According to MyFitnessPal dietitian Katherine Basbaum, obtaining prebiotics and probiotics through whole foods is ideal. However, if you choose to drink prebiotic sodas, opt for ones that contain both prebiotics and probiotics, as they work synergistically to support gut health.
Key Ingredients in Prebiotic Sodas
When selecting a prebiotic soda, Basbaum recommends looking for the following ingredients, which are commonly found in gut-healthy sodas. While generally safe, individual sensitivities should be considered.
Inulin
Inulin, a popular prebiotic, is often derived from chicory root. While it supports gut health, it may cause gas or bloating in some individuals, depending on their tolerance.
Apple Cider Vinegar
Fermented apple cider vinegar naturally contains probiotics. Though research on its benefits is limited, it is generally considered safe in moderation.
Stevia and Artificial Sweeteners
Stevia and other artificial sweeteners can reduce added sugar content. Some studies suggest Stevia may even mimic probiotic effects in the gut. However, some people may experience sensitivity to these ingredients.
Added Sugar
Choose prebiotic sodas with minimal added sugars, even if they contain natural sugars from fruit flavors.
Pros and Cons of Prebiotic Sodas
Benefits
- Lower sugar and calorie content
- Potential source of fiber
- Supports gut health for those who tolerate prebiotics well
Drawbacks
- Not a reliable source of nutrition
- Should not replace whole, fiber-rich foods
- Not a complete substitute for water
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the healthiest prebiotic soda on the market?
Look for options with probiotics, minimal added sugars, and prebiotics like inulin.
Is prebiotic soda better than diet soda?
Prebiotic soda is generally a healthier choice, as it offers some nutritional value, unlike diet sodas.
Do fruit-flavored prebiotic sodas differ nutritionally from other flavors?
Regardless of flavor, always check the nutritional facts for added sugars and ingredients.
How much prebiotic soda should I drink?
Start with no more than one serving daily and monitor how your body responds.
The Bottom Line
Prebiotic sodas can offer some nutritional benefits but should not replace whole foods in your diet. As Basbaum notes, "Whole foods are still the gold standard for gut health." Think of prebiotic sodas as an occasional treat rather than a health solution—they’re a smarter choice than sugary sodas, but they’re no substitute for a balanced, fiber-rich diet.
This article, "Gut-Check: The Truth About Prebiotic Sodas Taking Over Your Grocery Aisles," first appeared on the MyFitnessPal Blog.
