Trump rejects Supreme Court bid to end ‘DEI’ grants | Today’s news
The U.S. Supreme Court has defeated President Donald Trump in his bid to cancel billions of dollars in federal grants, upholding a ruling that the administration likely acted illegally by targeting research projects it said were “DEI programs.”
Justices on Monday rejected the administration’s appeal in a clash with UC faculty members and researchers without recording a dissent.
The rejection upholds a federal appeals court ruling that, for now, requires the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities to continue funding $59 million in grants. The San Francisco-based 9th Circuit Court said Trump likely violated the Constitution’s free speech clause by discriminating against grant recipients because of their opinions.
“It means that the 9th Circuit’s decision stands and all grants that were terminated based on the perceived bias of the research must continue to be renewed,” said Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of law at the University of California, Berkeley, and lead attorney for the researchers. He said the appeals court’s decision would also serve as an “important precedent” for other courts around the country.
Even as the high court sidesteps the case, it leaves unanswered questions about the controversy that raged during Trump’s first months in office last year. Trump ordered the agencies to end the grants, which included diversity, equity and inclusion, as well as “gender ideology” and “environmental justice.”
The Justice Department said it “will continue to defend the executive branch’s statutory authority to administer federal funding programs and to terminate taxpayer-funded DEI initiatives.”
In its challenge, the Trump administration argued that the Constitution allows the government to choose to fund only those projects that align with its vision. U.S. Solicitor General D. John Sauer told the justices that the decision by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals would “cripple any future administration” if not overturned.
“The First Amendment gives the government considerable flexibility when it acts as a patron to subsidize speech,” argued Sauer, the administration’s lead courtroom attorney. “Government can itself promote preferred views, including disbursement of public funds to private entities.”
In rejecting the government, the 9th Circuit said the Supreme Court had distinguished between deciding not to fund the program at all and rejecting specific applicants because of their views.
“Because the termination of agency grants is aimed at suppressing views with which the government disagrees, it arguably violates the First Amendment,” the appeals court said in a 3-0 decision.
The University of California group urged the Supreme Court not to hear the case, saying the 9th Circuit was applying “clearly settled law.” Researchers said the crash ended cutting-edge studies in science, medicine and other fields.
“The stakes for researchers and for the public who benefit from their work could not be higher,” the group told the high court.
Much of the grant cancellation took place under the Department of Government Efficiency, an effort led by Elon Musk that tore through the federal government last year, laying off workers, eliminating agencies and cutting billions of dollars in spending. DOGE, as the office is known, claimed to have canceled $110 billion in grants and contracts, although the actual savings to the government may have been far less.
The administration criticized the wholesale and, at least in some cases, erratic nature of the terminations. The New York Times reported in March that DOGE officials relied on ChatGPT to select which National Endowment for the Humanities grants to focus on.
In the University of California case, researchers accused the administration of relying on keywords, including “diversity,” to determine which grants were problematic. This approach is said to have been taken in projects with titles mentioning “Leaf Diversity” and “Diversity in Legume Rhizobia Mutualism”.
The case is Trump v. Thakur, 26-210.
With the help of Gregory Korte.
This article was generated from an automated news agency source without text modification.