The US presents an unprecedented Donbas proposal: Would Ukraine give up its eastern territory to Russia for NATO membership? | Today’s news

During recent peace talks with Russia, the United States raised the possibility of withdrawing Ukraine from its eastern Donbas region in exchange for NATO membership, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said.

The issue was discussed during the latest round of talks with representatives of the US, Ukraine and Russia in Abu Dhabi. Zelenskyy said it was the first time Washington had explicitly linked Ukraine’s potential NATO membership with territorial concessions during negotiations.

“The Americans raised the question: ‘What if Ukraine joins NATO? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?'” Zelenskyy told reporters in remarks released by his office on Saturday.

The Ukrainian president described the problem as extremely difficult and pointed to Russia’s long-standing opposition to Ukraine’s entry into the Western military alliance.

Moscow has repeatedly viewed NATO’s eastward expansion and Kyiv’s membership ambitions as security threats, with Russian President Vladimir Putin citing the issue among his justifications for launching a large-scale invasion in February 2022.

Zelenskyy repeated that Ukraine is not ready to give up its territory. He said any possible decision would depend on a comprehensive package of security guarantees, military support and financial aid, and that he would put such an arrangement to a national referendum.

What is the US proposal regarding Donbass?

The reported discussion centers on whether Ukraine could withdraw from Donbas as part of a broader deal that would secure its future NATO membership.

Donbass, an industrial region in eastern Ukraine that includes Donetsk and Luhansk, has been one of the biggest obstacles in negotiations to end the war. Russian forces have occupied large parts of the region, while Moscow continues to demand that Kiev withdraw from the remaining areas under Ukrainian control.

Putin has previously made Ukraine’s withdrawal from the Donbass a condition of a peace deal. In September 2022, Russia announced the annexation of Donetsk and Luhansk along with Kherson and Zaporizhia following referendums held in the occupied territories. Ukraine and most of the international community rejected the vote and annexation as illegal.

Moscow has also maintained its claim to Crimea, which it annexed in 2014. Neither the United States nor the United Nations recognize Russia’s annexation claims.

Read also | Kushner wants direct Russian-European negotiations on Ukraine peace pressure

Zelensky’s latest comments suggest Washington may be exploring whether NATO membership could be part of a compromise over territory. However, rather than a confirmed agreement or a formal proposal accepted by either party, his description describes an issue raised by American negotiators.

What security guarantees is Ukraine looking for?

Zelenskyy said Kyiv would need firm security guarantees before considering any territorial compromise. He called for safeguards along the lines of Article 5 of the NATO treaty, which stipulates that an armed attack against one member is to be considered an attack against all members.

He said the security package being discussed should include NATO and European Union guarantees, an adequately equipped and funded Ukrainian army, enough troops and weapons, and financial aid for reconstruction.

Zelenskyy argued that such assurances would be essential to prevent Russia from launching another attack after a ceasefire or peace deal.

The Ukrainian president also said that any potential deal involving territorial concessions would have to be submitted to the Ukrainian people in a referendum. His position remains that Kyiv will not give up its territory voluntarily.

Why is NATO membership a problem for Russia?

Ukraine’s ambition to join NATO has been a central source of tension between Moscow and the West for years.

NATO’s collective defense clause, Article 5, means that an attack on one member is considered an attack on the entire alliance.

Membership would therefore offer Ukraine a much stronger security commitment than a conventional bilateral agreement.

Putin has repeatedly spoken out against Ukraine’s NATO ambitions, arguing that the alliance’s presence near Russia’s borders threatens Moscow’s security.

Read also | Decoded: How Trump-Putin talks could reshape NATO and Europe’s security order

As part of negotiations to end the war, Russia sought assurances that Ukraine would not join the alliance.

Can Ukraine agree to give up Donbass?

The latest discussions highlight the difficult decisions Ukraine faces as diplomatic efforts to end the war continue.

Zelensky’s comments indicate that Ukraine is willing to discuss the terms of a possible settlement, but not to accept territorial concessions without substantial guarantees in return.

The proposal also runs into a major obstacle: Putin’s opposition to Ukraine’s NATO membership.

Even if Kiev were to consider withdrawing from Donbass, there is no indication that Moscow would accept Ukraine’s entry into the alliance as compensation.

With information from Reuters.

Similar Posts