The SIR exercise is also a failure of technology

“India presents itself, with ample reason to do so, as a leader in digital public infrastructure… But when it comes to one of the most fundamental processes of any democracy, the revision of electoral rolls, India has failed to utilize this capability” | Photo credit: Shiv Kumar Pushpakar

Much of the public controversy about Special Intensive Review (SIR) Indian electoral rolls are about law, power and politics. The autonomy of the Election Commission of India (ECI), the list of acceptable documents and the burden placed on voters to prove eligibility are the key issues we focus on. Of course, there is no doubt that these issues matter. But beneath them runs a quieter, less spoken story. SIR 2025-26 is the first revision of this scale to be done through a centralized digital platform and technology itself has become a source of exclusion. Seen as a nationwide digital transformation project, SIR fails on several points that any student of technology would immediately recognize.

Irony stares right at us. India presents itself, with ample reason to do so, as a leader in digital public infrastructure. From the IRCTC (Indian Railway Catering and Tourism Corporation) ticketing system and the Income Tax department’s e-filing to Aadhaar authentication, UPI, DigiLocker, etc., India has proven at home and abroad that it can create technology that works at scale.

Published – 13 Nov 2026 02:28 IST