The dual reporting structures built into Bengaluru’s new police system are raising concerns
R. Hithendra, Bengaluru’s 40th Superintendent of Police, with Chief Minister DK Shivakumar after assuming charge, in Bengaluru on Wednesday. | Photo credit: SPECIAL ARRANGEMENT
The restructuring of Bengal’s city police to five commissioners with a chief commissioner has several dual reporting structures built into it, which could potentially cause administrative problems, several senior police officials said on Wednesday, following the government’s restructuring order. They pointed out that hierarchy and chain of command were key in the police and were not clear in the new organizational structure, although roles also have yet to be properly defined.
For example, the five commissioners of police will report directly to the director general and inspector general of police (DG&IGP), Karnataka, the order says, but while defining the role of the chief commissioner, it has been stated that he will supervise the five commissioners. The order even acknowledges the confusion and says that any clarification on the mutual powers and functions of the Chief Commissioner of Police and the five Commissioners of Police will be clarified by the government for their smooth functioning. While the chain of command for police functions in the city remains clear, both traffic and crime appear to be marked by dual reporting structures that can cause confusion and stress lower bureaucracies due to conflicting orders and hinder a coherent strategy.
For the traffic police, it has created another layer of confusion for Deputy Commissioners of Police (DCPs) as they will now have to report to both local commissioners and the Commissioner of Police (Traffic). Speaking to The Hindu, senior officers who earlier held the post of traffic DCPs in the city said the new hierarchy could cause complications in getting approvals, planning and coordinating with civic bodies.
At present, all the planning functions of the Bengaluru Traffic Police fall under the Joint Commissioner of Police. While the new order places responsibility for urban transport planning on the Commissioner of Police (Traffic), it is not clear which aspects the transport DCP will have to report to local commissioners.
While each commissioner has a DCP (crime), there is also an additional commissioner (Anti-Rowdy Squad) at the city level, both expected to replace the erstwhile Central Crime Branch. Hemanth M. Nimbalkar was also tasked with “supervising crime control” across the city. This also created a dual crime reporting structure.
A senior police officer said the hierarchy could create pressure, the effects of which would trickle down to inspectors and junior officers. “For example, if we have a case in hand and one officer suggests one method of investigation and another suggests another, which of the two should the DCP choose? This could further trickle down to the inspector if the pressure on the DCP mounts,” the officer explained.
Even planning at the local level, including crime monitoring and policing strategies, could be affected by these conflicts, leading to significant strain on officers and delays in implementing plans, the officer said.
Published – 19 Nov 2026 0:30 AM IST