Bravo cameras captured Paige DeSorbo and Craig Conover spending time together last summer before their breakup. During Summer House Season 9, Episode 3, which aired on February 26, Paige revealed she was considering freezing her eggs and mentioned that Craig had already frozen his sperm. The episode was filmed in July-August 2024, and the couple split shortly after, ending their three-year relationship.
Paige recalled their conversation: "I said, ‘I should probably freeze my eggs.’ And he replied, ‘Oh, should I freeze my sperm?’" She added that Craig’s test results were "perfectly fine" and "above average." Her remarks about potentially starting a family with Craig are just one of many moments from the season that viewers may find bittersweet.
Here’s a breakdown of some quotes from Paige and Craig during Season 9 that didn’t quite age well:
Italian Memories
During the Season 9 premiere on February 12, Paige shared details about a recent trip to Italy with Craig and her family. "It was so nice," she said, mentioning Craig joined for four or five days. She joked to Ciara Miller, "My brother and I kept telling Craig to shut up every time he talked."
Pregnancy Scares
Paige opened up about her feelings on motherhood after fellow cast member Lindsay Hubbard revealed her pregnancy. (Lindsay welcomed her daughter Gemma in December 2024.) Paige reflected on her younger self, saying, "I used to think, ‘You get a job, get married, and have a baby.’ I’ve grown up and learned since then." She confessed, "Craig is ready to marry and have a baby, and I’m still… not."
Feeling "Bad" for Craig
During the February 19 episode, Paige gave fans insight into her evolving relationship with Craig. After discussing plans over FaceTime, she admitted, "This will feel a bit backward, but I feel a little bad for Craig because I’m a completely different person than the girl he started dating three years ago." She explained, "I’m busier, I’m not as carefree, and I’ve changed my mind on a lot of things, like marriage, moving in together, and having kids." Paige added, "I won’t apologize for being busier or thinking differently, but I also recognize that I’ve changed a lot."
Not Ready for Kids
In Episode 2, Paige shared that Lindsay’s pregnancy gave her anxiety about her own relationship. She reflected, "Craig and I started dating, then Lindsay and Carl Radke got engaged, planned a wedding, called it off, found new partners, and now she’s pregnant—and I’m still with Craig." Paige admitted, "I feel pressured to have a baby, but I’m not ready."
No More Stay-at-Home Plans
During the February 26 episode, Paige revealed Craig had been ready for her to move in and start a family, but she wasn’t on the same page. "Craig was ready for us to be a family and for me to move to his house—he literally texted me about it," she said. "But I’ve worked for this moment in my career for 10 years." She added, "I used to dream about staying in bed, being taken care of, and saying, ‘Now I’m done.’ But that’s not where I’m at."
Related: Summer House Season 9 Preview
In an extended preview of Season 9, Paige made shocking allegations about Craig, claiming he had texted other women during their relationship. The preview, released after the February 12 premiere, hinted at the drama to come this season.
Summer House airs on Bravo every Wednesday at 9 PM ET.
