Strange fate of ‘captain’s dream’: India’s decision to drop Mohammed Siraj makes no sense
Indian captain Shubman Gill and Mohammed Siraj clash during the fourth day of the fifth Test match between India and England at The Oval cricket ground in London. (PTI Photo) Mohammed Siraj cannot play in T20Is, he is no longer a regular in the Indian ODI side and now, even in the format where he has been most convincing, the Indian pacer has been left out of the playing XI. Siraj last played a Test in SENA’s country at The Oval in August 2025, where he took nine wickets in the match to help India secure a famous victory and level the series against England. In Wellington, however, India missed out on their second best fast bowler in Test cricket in the last few years. It is difficult to understand the reasons behind the decision of the team management.After the win at The Oval, Shubman Gill called Siraj a “captain’s dream”. At the draw in Wellington, the Indian skipper admitted it was a “tough decision” to leave him out. But acknowledging how difficult the selection process was does not necessarily explain why it was carried out.Siraj took 144 wickets in 48 Tests, 108 of which came at away or neutral venues. He has become the bowler India can turn to when the ball is not moving or when the wicket has little or no help. He did it alongside Jasprit Bumrah and sometimes in his absence. His value to the team goes beyond his goals. His contribution was not just about goals. Siraj put his body on, played long spells and kept coming back because the team needed it.His omission is more difficult to understand because the uncertainty surrounding his place is not limited to one format. He hasn’t played T20Is regularly, his ODI opportunities have been sporadic and now his place in the Test side also seems expendable. Talking about how regular bowling helps him find his rhythm, Siraj says that the more he bowls, the better he feels.Fast bowling depends on rhythm, repetition and confidence. Keeping a bowler like Siraj, who has been the mainstay of India’s attack, in and out of the fold won’t necessarily help him find any of these things.The reasons for his exclusion are also difficult to justify. Gill said before the match that India would play four pacers “just to be safe” and hinted that Kamboj and Akash Deep or Nitish Reddy could make the XI because of their batting prowess. Between Kamboj and Nitish Reddy, Kamboj was clearly the better choice as a bowling specialist who can contribute with the bat rather than a batsman who mixes it up on occasion.India’s latest combination in Wellington makes Siraj’s omission even harder to defend. Washington Sundar was already in the eleven as an all-rounder while the choice between Akash Deep and Anshul Kamboj was a sensible one. Kamboj offers something with the bat but is also a bowling specialist. Picking one of these two would give India another seam option without affecting the balance of the side.Instead, India picked both and left out Siraj. Basin Reserve had a green surface and India won the toss and elected to bowl. The team wanted to take advantage of the conditions but missed one of their bowling mainstays.As Gill explained at the toss, dropping Siraj was a combo call. India decided to provide some extra batting cover at the expense of the strike bowler. That’s a questionable compromise in any Test, but more so against a New Zealand side that India haven’t beaten in a Test on a tour of the country since 2009.