Pat Cummins discredited Usman Khawaja the man, it was shocking: R Ashwin

Former India spinner R Ashwin has criticized Pat Cummins for the way the Australian captain responded to Usman Khawaja’s revelations about the Sandpapergate scandal in 2018, saying he was surprised by the personal nature of the remarks directed at the former Australian opener.

Speaking on JioHotstar’s Sandpapergate: The Unsettled Debate, Ashwin said Cummins questioned Khawaja’s character rather than simply challenging his version of events in his recently released autobiography Sabr.

“But what happened in Pat Cummins’ press conference is that he didn’t discredit Usman Khawaj’s account of the story, he discredited the man himself. And that’s a problem for me. If you can’t discredit someone’s information, you discredit the person,” Ashwin said.

The former India spinner, who played alongside Khawaja, vouched for the Australian’s character and said he did not expect Cummins to react in such a manner.

“I know Usman Khawaja, I’ve played a lot of cricket with him; not on a personal front, he’s a man of high integrity and a really honest and straightforward person and I would really think Pat wouldn’t discredit that man in this particular case,” he added.

The dispute resurfaced after Khawaja’s bookhe returned to Australia’s ball-tampering scandal during the 2018 tour of South Africa. Khawaja wrote that knowledge of the use of sandpaper was more widespread in the team than subsequent investigations suggested. He also recounted how he was sitting next to Cameron Bancroft when he was told to be careful when using sandpaper.

Cummins responded to the revelation at a press conference last week in Sydney, strongly rejected the suggestion that the Australian bowling group knew about the plan.

“When he says we all knew, if he means we knew there was sandpaper on the field, he’s 100 percent wrong,” Cummins said.

He also dismissed Khawaja’s suggestion that he and other bowlers were the architects of the ball-tampering scheme, calling it “complete and utter nonsense”. Cummins said he was particularly shocked by Khawaja’s account of Bancroft’s warning and questioned why the former opener did not intervene.

However, Ashwin highlighted another aspect of the controversy. He pointed to a 2021 statement issued by Australia’s fast-bowling group, which included Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon, after Bancroft’s comments again cast doubt on the bowlers’ knowledge of the incident. The pitchers refused to participate.

“My truth, your truth, and the truth.” R Ashwin opens up on Usman Khawaja’s book and why the cricket world should read, learn and move on ahead of the #ToughestRivalry! Watch the broadcast of Sandpapergate: The Unsettled Debate on JioHotstar! Coming soon #BorderGavaskarTrophy | #INDvAUS starts 21 Jan 2027!— Star Sports (@StarSportsIndia) November 17, 2026

“VERY SURPRISED BY CUMMINS”

Ashwin said reconsidering the position will be difficult for the players who made the statement. He also pointed out that Cummins was relatively inexperienced during the 2018 tour of South Africa and was not part of the Australian leadership group at the time.

“I really would have thought that this conversation would have come round and said, you know, ‘I didn’t know about exactly what was going on, I wasn’t part of the leadership group.’ It was very surprising to me that Pat Cummins had to come to a press conference and discredit the man himself,” Ashwin said.

Cummins’ reaction also drew criticism from the former Australian vice-captain David Warner who supported Khawaja and accused the current captain of throwing his former teammate under the bus.

“I still stand by Uzzy and what he wrote in that book. It’s true and I really, really support him,” Warner said on Fox Cricket.

Warner also questioned the handling of the original investigation, calling it botched and saying Khawaja was not interviewed despite being in the dressing room during the South Africa tour.

The 2018 scandal resulted in one-year bans for Steve Smith and Warner, while Bancroft received a nine-month ban. Cricket Australia chief executive Todd Greenberg has since ruled out reopening the investigation.

– The end