New York City Horse Carriage Ban Unconstitutional, Court Says | Today’s news

(Bloomberg Law) — New York City’s brand new law banning horse-drawn carriages is unconstitutional, unions representing carriage operators and owners said in a federal lawsuit filed Thursday seeking to block the measure.

The City Council-approved ban signed Thursday by Mayor Zohran Mamdani (D) will phase out the 168-year-old industry before taking effect June 1, 2028, in all five boroughs. The law requires “humane treatment” of horses and prohibits them from being sold for slaughter or transferred to other transport companies. There are currently 68 horse cabs operating in Central Park, employing roughly 200 drivers and up to 160 horses.

The law will “immediately cripple” carriage owners and ignore property interests and contracts, the Transport Workers Union Local 100 said in a class-action lawsuit filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.

The union is seeking a temporary injunction and a preliminary injunction that would block enforcement of the law until the court decides on the merits. He is also asking the court for an expedited finding.

The city’s legal department said it was reviewing the case.

The legislation, known as Romanche’s Law, was passed after the death of 18-year-old Romanche Mahajan, who was killed over the summer after being thrown from a horse-drawn carriage in Central Park. The city has tried for decades to ban horse-drawn carriages — a tourist staple of Central Park that has existed since 1858.

The new law does not include compensation for property — such as permits and licenses, stables and horses — that are now “unusable,” the complaint said. They are only talking about a potential compensation plan that could come later. That’s a violation of the U.S. Constitution, which prohibits “takings” without just compensation, the union says.

It also “makes vague promises of a ‘transition plan’ that offers affected carriage drivers only ‘assistance’ in finding ’employment opportunities,'” the complaint states.

Mamdani said at Thursday’s public signing ceremony that the city plans to release a transition plan in April that will include a process for the city to buy back the medallions — operating licenses and tags — from owners, a stipend for drivers and stable hands to attend employee training and career development classes, and career counseling and business support.

The city will work directly with horse-drawn carriage workers to get and incorporate their feedback into the transition process, the mayor said. And the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene will oversee where any horses are sold or placed when they retire, he added.

“This is a new day for our city — a day that will make the crown jewel of Manhattan’s parks safer while recognizing the lasting legacy and contributions that the horse-drawn carriage industry has brought to our city,” Mamdani said.

Advocates for Justice is represented by the Transport Workers Union.

The case is Chiarello v. City of New York, SDNY, 1:26-cv-10154, complaint 11/19/26.

To contact the reporters for this story: Beth Wang in New York at bwang@bloombergindustry.com; Patricia Hurtado at pathurtado@bloomberg.net

To contact the editors responsible for this story: Carmen Castro-Pagán at ccastro-pagan@bloomberglaw.com; Andrew Harris at aharris@bloomberglaw.com

More such stories are available at bloomberg.com