Neither popular nor right: Dropping Siraj in Wellington was a bad call by Gambhir

Gautam Gambhir has never been one to shy away from defending an unpopular decision. The Indian head coach has often spoken of preferring the right calls over the popular ones, even when they attract criticism. It is a philosophy that has defined several selection decisions, including his reluctance to field Vaibhav Sooryavanshi in the T20I side despite the teenager’s extraordinary season in IPL 2026. Gambhir and the team management chose to back Sanja Samson and Abhishek Sharma, the opening pair that performed during India’s T20 World Cup triumph, rather than making a change simply because public opinion demanded it. That belief was justified.

IND vs NZ 1st Test Day 1: MAIN | SCORECARD

But a philosophy is only as good as the decisions it makes. In Wellington, on the opening day of an important Test series, the Gambhir-led team management’s call to leave Mohammed Siraj out of the playing eleven was neither popular nor, more importantly, correct. It was a poor call that looked increasingly difficult to justify as New Zealand recovered from 70 for 5 to reach 243 for 5 at stumps.

It wasn’t just a surprise that Siraj dropped out. India opted for four specialist fast bowlers, but one of their most reliable overseas players was not among them. Jasprit Bumrah, Akash Deep, Prasidh Krishna and Anshul Kamboj made the XI, leaving Siraj to watch from the sidelines. It was a choice that needed explaining, especially on the surface at Basin Reserve, which offered assistance to sailors early in the morning.

Sunil Gavaskar was not only surprised by the decision. He was confused. In an interview with Sony Sports, the former Indian captain questioned how a bowler who was relied upon so heavily until recently could suddenly fall outside the team’s preferred back four.

“It didn’t surprise me; it confused me. It confused me to think that a bowler you relied on so heavily until September-October last year, even when there were Test matches in India, you relied on him – and he’s not in your top four?” Gavaskar said.

He went on to question whether Siraj’s bowling had deteriorated so dramatically or whether his position among the decision-makers had declined.

“Nothing wrong with his bowling. His rhythm is good. From what I have observed in any cricket he has played recently, he has been fine. Why he has not been selected, I don’t know,” Gavaskar said.

MISSED INDIA SIRAJ?

There is a reason why Siraj’s omission is particularly difficult to understand. His value for India in overseas conditions has rarely been limited to the wicket column. He’s a bounce-back pitcher who can shoulder a heavy workload and has a knack for injecting life into the offense when the game starts to drift. This quality is not always captured by a recent summary of results.

India’s last major Test assignment in SENA terms, the five-Test tour of England in 2025, was a reminder of just that. Siraj played every Test, bowled 185.3 overs, the most by an Indian bowler on tour, and finished with 23 wickets. He was a constant presence in attack, going through long spells and difficult passages, often with little respite.

The defining picture came at The Oval where India pulled off a remarkable six-run victory to level the series at 2-2. When the final morning began, England needed just 35 runs with four wickets in hand. The home side had the advantage, the crowd was behind them and India, without Bumrah, who did not play this Test, seemed to be running out of options. But Siraj kept coming. He finished with nine wickets in the match, including five in the second innings, as India turned a precarious position into one of their most memorable overseas wins. It was the kind of performance that explained why the team continues to trust the pitcher, even if his numbers elsewhere aren’t very flattering.

And yet in Wellington, Siraj was limited to wearing a training bib and watching from the sidelines.

To be fair, India’s decision initially seemed to work. Bumrah was excellent with the new ball and troubled New Zealand’s top order with his movement and control. Kamboj made an immediate impression while Akash Deep provided useful support. New Zealand were reduced to 70 for 5 and India had every reason to believe they were on their way to a dominant opening day. But Test cricket is rarely decided by the first burst of fast bowling magic. The challenge is to ask questions even after the new ball has lost its luster, the pitch has settled and the batsmen have found their feet.

This was where India struggled. Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips took full advantage and put together an unbeaten partnership of 173 runs for the sixth wicket. They ran hard, rotated the strike and punished loose deliveries without taking any unnecessary risks. India went 53.4 overs without a wicket as New Zealand turned a precarious position into a competitive total.

The captain’s fielding and bowling changes were also open. Gill is still learning the demands of leading a Test side and there were passages when India seemed content to let the partnership develop rather than force the issue. Nicholls and Phillips simply did not survive; they took the game away from India with smart batting and sharp running. The visitors needed a change of pace, a spell that could unsettle the pair and restore some urgency. It didn’t arrive too often.

Bumrah did the damage but he couldn’t be expected to do everything. Kamboj and Akash Deep contributed early, but the attack lacked the same bite once the ball got old and the conditions became less useful. Prasidh Krishna struggled to build sustained pressure while Bumrah too could not sustain his initial intensity during the final session. The offense needed someone capable of taking over when the early lead disappeared.

Siraj is just such a bowler. His greatest strength is not that he takes a wicket every time India needs one. It’s that he rarely lets the game die down around him. His wobbly seam and mixed seam, his ability to operate from a wide crease and his willingness to mix in long spells make him valuable when the surface stops offering extravagant movement. More than anything, it brings energy. He can run for another spell when the attack looks tired and has repeatedly shown the ability to lift a side in the field when the competition starts to fade.

This is not to say that Siraj would definitely break the Nicholls-Phillips partnership. Cricket doesn’t work that way and hindsight cannot determine what might have happened if he had played. But India had bowlers with a proven track record of maintaining pressure in overseas conditions and chose not to use him on a day when that was exactly what they needed.

‘THEY DID NOT SURPRISE ME’

Simon Doull, speaking to Sony Sports after matchday, was equally unconvinced by the decision, although he had expected it. The former New Zealand fast bowler said the team’s behavior towards Siraj during the previous ODI series offered clues that he is unlikely to perform in the Test. Still, he didn’t believe it was the right choice.

“The fact that he’s not playing I think is bad but I’m not surprised because they haven’t played him through the ODIs,” Doull said. He pointed to the decision to send Gurnoor Brar to the ODI squad and give Siraj an opportunity only in the final match as an indication of the team’s mindset. “But do I think it was the right decision? No.”

There is, of course, another side to the argument. Siraj’s recent test returns have not been spectacular. He has taken just 14 wickets in his last 12 Test outings. His tour of India AND New Zealand yielded four wickets for 118 runs. Team management has the right to look beyond reputation and past performance when choosing a side. But should Siraj’s recent numbers outweigh his record in conditions far more relevant to the Wellington task?

Since his debut, Siraj has taken 91 wickets in SENA countries at an average of 31.04, with four five-wicket hauls. Only Bumrah, with 113 wickets, has taken more among Indian bowlers in these conditions. These are not numbers based on reputation.

India’s batting coach Sitanshu Kotak defended the decision after the day’s play, insisting that nothing bad had happened to Siraj and that the team had chosen what they felt was their best combination. “There is nothing wrong with Siraj. When we picked the side, we thought this is the best XI. I don’t think dropping Siraj was a bad decision. This is just the first day. We are not only picking the team for the first day but also for the two, three and four days,” Kotak told reporters.

That’s a fair point in isolation. The Test XI must be selected keeping in mind the five days, not just the conditions on the day of the draw. But it also begs the question: what was the long-term consideration that made Siraj expendable? If India wanted an attack capable of adapting as the pitch flattened and the ball got older, why leave out a bowler whose greatest asset is his ability to carry on when the conditions aren’t helpful?

India is not out of the running. At 243 for 5 they kept New Zealand within reach and the early morning ball work was impressive. But this should not obscure the question of choice. Siraj was an ace that India could keep up their sleeve for the long haul. Instead, they decided to leave him out altogether. Gambhir may not make popular calls, but he made a call in Wellington that was neither popular nor correct.

– The end