Magnus Carlsen’s controversial issue is losing its domino effect! The other two GMs skip games in Total Chess Pilot

Magnus Carlsen, Richard Rapport and Abhimanyu Mishra World No.1 Magnus Carlsen’s decision to forfeit his Fast Classic games after taking an unassailable lead set off a ripple effect at the Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot, with two more grandmasters opting out of their matches on Wednesday.India’s R Vaishali and Armenia’s Haik Martirosyan were left waiting in the playing hall after their opponents Abhimanyu Mishra and Richard Rapport decided not to turn up for the final games of the Fast Classic. The development comes after Carlsen sparked controversy by withdrawing from her matches against Kazakhstan’s Bibisara Assaubaeva on consecutive days.While Carlsen’s actions have already raised questions about sportsmanship and the rules of the tournament, Mishra and Rapport’s decisions have added another layer to the debate over the format.

Mishra explains the decision after Vaishali scores eight points

Competing for the 21st to 24th spots, 17-year-old Mishra entered the final match with an 11-1 lead over Vaishali after winning the opening day’s match 13-7. He also clinched the match on the second day before the Fast Classic, building an advantage with blitz and quick games.Mishra chose not to play the final contest and handed Vaishali all eight points on offer. However, his 11-9 victory on the day’s aggregate meant he won the tie and progressed.“There’s nothing to say,” Vaishali said as she walked off the board.He will now face Uzbekistan’s Nodirbek Abdusattorov in a match to avoid last place in the tournament.Mishra later approached X to explain his decision, citing fatigue after a grueling schedule and uncertainty as to whether the remaining games in already decided matches would count towards player ratings.“Nothing to say,” was Vaishali’s curt response, while Mishra said he approached the chief umpire well in advance to seek permission not to play.“Well before the next game I approached the head umpires to ask if it would be acceptable for me not to show up. She told me that the decision was entirely up to me and that it was perfectly acceptable not to play,” he wrote.He added that the tough schedule, along with uncertainty about the ratings implications of the remaining games, influenced his decision.“Given that uncertainty combined with the fatigue I felt, plus permission from the chief umpire, I had sufficient reasons not to turn up,” Mishra said.

Rapport will also skip a game after losing a tie

Rapport’s decision came in a different context. The Hungarian grandmaster had already lost a tie against Martirosyan and was trailing 2-10 on the second day after losing the opening day match 9-11.He subsequently lost the Fast Classic, leaving Martirosyan unopposed for the final encounter.The two transfers followed Carlsen’s repeated decision to skip the final match against Assaubayev after taking the lead in their two-day tie.

Carlsen’s actions put the tournament format under scrutiny

Carlsen had already secured an 11-point lead against Assaubayev on the opening day after winning three of four blitz games and two quick games. He then lost the match to Fast Classic, giving up all eight points he had to his opponent, but still won today’s match 11.5-8.5.The Norwegian repeated the move on Wednesday after building a 10-2 lead with blitz and quick plays. Assaubayeva again scored eight points to tie the score for the day at 10-10. However, Carlsen advanced on the strength of his opening day win.Explaining his decision, Carlsen said the final game had little meaning once it was decided.“There will be no classic game, as I understand it, the match is over. The only consequence of not showing up is that you will lose a completely meaningless game,” he was quoted as saying by Norwegian TV2.Carlsen also admitted that he did not want to play more classical chess in the classification match.“It’s an uncomfortable situation, I’d rather not play so classically anymore,” he said on Tuesday.Norway’s decision drew criticism, with US Grandmaster Hans Niemann objecting to preferential treatment and insisting that the rules should apply equally to all players. FIDE executive advisor Emil Sutovsky described the behavior as unsportsmanlike, while India’s Olympic captain Srinath Narayanan also criticized the lack of civility.

Organizers are monitoring feedback ahead of the 2027 edition

Controversy also focused on tournament rules, particularly the importance of Fast Classic games after a player has already qualified.Total Chess CEO Kjell Madland said the Budapest pilot was intended to help organizers assess the format and identify possible improvements ahead of the inaugural edition in March 2027.“The Budapest pilot is an important learning exercise for Total Chess. While we have developed the format and rules with considerable thought and input, the real test is how they perform in a live competitive environment,” Madland said in a statement.He added that organizers wanted feedback directly from players and referees before deciding whether changes were necessary.Organizers did not immediately confirm whether Carlsen’s falls would be automatically penalized. With Mishra and Rapport now also skipping their final games, the issue became more pressing: whether the format needed clearer rules to ensure that each scheduled game was handled consistently, regardless of whether the match had already been decided.