Lost Job Because of Asking a Question During an Interview: LinkedIn User Shares Personal Experience, “Be Prepared in Case…” | Today’s news
Karan Gogna shared a career story on LinkedIn. He described losing a job offer because of one question. The user, now a senior product manager, successfully passed each round of the interview. HR has already asked for his documents to proceed. That evening HR called again to meet the CEO.
The company was a used car startup. Gogna decided to simply give it his best effort. The interview with the CEO went smoothly at first. He felt that the CEO was really impressed. He already imagined that the offer letter was coming.
Read also | I asked ChatGPT to prepare me for a job interview: AI gives key questions and answers
The CEO then asked if he had any questions. Gogna wanted it to sound sharp, he asked something sharp. He asked if they were planning to enter the two-wheeler market. The CEO turned it around and asked Gogna for his opinion.
Gogna thoroughly researched the ATV space beforehand. However, he had nothing prepared on two-wheelers. He fumbled for an answer that lacked real substance.
The next day, HR sent an email with disappointing news. Instead, they proceeded with another candidate. His profile will simply remain in their system.
Gogna knew exactly where the conversation had gone wrong. It wasn’t the interview itself, but his last question. According to him, people rarely carefully prepare their own questions.
Read also | ‘Tell lies’: Recruiter shares tips on interview questions and answers
“We spend so much time preparing our answers and almost no time preparing our questions. Your final question is the last data point they’ll get about how you think, so treat it with the same seriousness. Know why you’re asking it and be prepared in case it backfires,” Gogna wrote on LinkedIn.
In a follow-up post, Gogna admitted that he was still thinking about that moment.
“The two-wheeler question still comes to mind years later. Funny how one line at the very end can cancel forty minutes of great conversation,” he wrote.
Reaction on social networks
LinkedIn users reacted with mixed views on the situation. One of them argued that blaming the question itself is misleading. He suggested that the real test was resolving the ambiguity afterwards.
“In my opinion it’s kind of stupid to turn the question back on the person who asked the question, but handling a situation like this live and being prepared is a different skill than just asking good questions as mentioned,” the user wrote.
Gogna agreed, admitting that better framing might have helped. He argued that mastering the moment matters most.
Read also | ‘Systemic racism’: Asian man starts using American name, gets job interviews
Another user shared a similar personal experience from his own interview. He once asked the founder about funding during tough markets. He later realized that this seemed disrespectful to the founders’ efforts.
“I was childish when I asked this. I remember the expression. Now I understand the pain it takes to build a company and knowingly/unknowingly not respecting it is really not good,” the user wrote.
One user offered a completely different perspective. He suggested that Gogna was essentially gassed. He argued that the responsibility rested with the interviewer, not Gogna.
“Turning the question back shows some issues you’ve missed. The sooner the better and in your case the willpower you took your chances with the question may have saved you,” the user commented.
