Lionel Messi’s ‘Lucky Referee’? England vs Argentina FIFA appointment sparks fresh debate

Argentine Lionel Messi (AP photo) The referee appointed for Wednesday’s 2026 World Cup semi-final between England and Argentina found himself in the spotlight before the ball was even kicked. Moroccan-American official Ismail Elfath will oversee the high-profile clash at the Atlanta Stadium, adding another significant piece to his growing resume. The 44-year-old will be officiating his fourth game at the tournament, having already officiated in Japan’s 2-2 draw with the Netherlands, Spain’s 1-0 win over Uruguay and Norway’s shock 2-1 win over Brazil in the round of 16. The assignment also brings an interesting subplot involving Argentina captain Lionel Messi. Elfath has been involved in several high-profile matches with the eight-time Ballon d’Or winner in recent years, leading some fans on social media to point out the unusual coincidence. During the 2022 FIFA World Cup in Qatar, Elfath served as the fourth official in the final between Argentina and France, where Messi scored twice before leading his country to victory in a penalty shootout. A year later, Elfath refereed the 2023 League Cup final, where Messi scored Inter Miami’s only goal against Nashville SC before the MLS club lifted the trophy after another penalty shootout. His record in Major League Soccer also attracted attention. Elfath has managed Inter Miami’s four matches involving Messi, with the Florida club winning each of those matches. The statistics fueled speculation online, with some supporters describing Elfath as a “lucky” referee for Messi. However, there is no evidence to suggest that the official showed any preference towards the Argentine star or any other player. The appointment comes during a tournament in which Argentina’s knockout victories over Egypt and Switzerland sparked significant debate over refereeing decisions. Egypt had a goal disallowed in the defeat, while Switzerland’s Breel Embolo was sent off following VAR intervention, prompting criticism from players and officials after both matches. The controversy has also sparked conspiracy theories on social media that claim FIFA favored Argentina during what is expected to be Messi’s last World Cup. Football’s governing body has consistently rejected these proposals. FIFA’s head of referees, Pierluigi Collina, recently defended referees, stressing that referees work independently and cannot be swayed by outside pressure. He also warned that unfounded allegations could expose officials and their families to abuse and threats, insisting that every decision is made in good faith. From a footballing point of view, Elfath is known for taking a firm disciplinary approach. He has shown eight yellow cards and one red card in his three matches at the 2026 World Cup, suggesting that both England and Argentina can expect a tightly controlled game. The semi-final is of immense importance to both nations. England are chasing their first World Cup final since lifting the trophy in 1966, while defending champions Argentina are looking to reach a second successive final as Messi continues his quest for another world title.