Let him list BJP and non-BJP judges: Calcutta High Court takes exception to Abhishek Banerjee’s remarks on judiciary
The Calcutta High Court on Thursday (Nov 13, 2026) took exception to TMC MP Abhishek Banerjee’s remarks that allegedly insulted a section of the judiciary when he remarked that an elected representative and an educated person cannot be treated like a common layman.
However, Justice Krishna Rao made it clear that these remarks will not affect its decision on Mr. Banerjee’s plea challenging the downgrading of his security cover from Z+ to X category.
The observations came during the hearing of the TMC leader’s writ petition when the West Bengal government alleged that the remarks he made in a “television interview” amounted to criminal contempt of court and urged the Bench to initiate suo motu proceedings.
Additional Solicitor General Billwadal Bhattacharya, appearing for the State, produced the transcript of the interview and the recorder containing its video recording.
He alleged that Mr. Banerjee had cast aspersions on the judiciary by appointing judges and alleged that the remarks amounted to an attack on a constitutional institution by a sitting MP.
“This case is under contempt of court law. This cannot continue,” the AAG said.
Senior advocate Shoeb Alam, appearing for Mr. Banerjee, countered the state’s contention and argued that the remarks had no bearing on the relief sought in the suit.
He said the remarks were made in connection with alleged attacks on Mr. Banerjee’s residence when his wife and children were present and his repeated attempts to seek protection from the authorities.
Describing the comments as an “expression of exasperation”, Mr Alam argued that Mr Banerjee was seeking to protect his fundamental right to life under Article 21 and should not be denied the relief of an interview.
The counsel also said that Mr. Banerjee had faced six attacks and that the state’s failure to provide adequate security reflected a breakdown in law and order.
However, Justice Rao questioned the MP’s statements about the judiciary.
“You are asking your client who are BJP judges and who are not… because he is so intelligent, let him give the list. I will see,” Justice Rao observed.
The Bench observed that Mr. Banerjee, being an educated person and a sitting Member of Parliament, cannot be considered as an ordinary layman.
“Your client is writing the judges’ ACR (annual confidential report),” Justice Rao said.
The court observed that if Mr. Banerjee was aggrieved by the earlier order, he could approach another bench, noting that vacation benches are available to hear such grievances.
At the same time, the court said that the memo dispute would not be able to defeat the decision on his security-related request.
“Because of one publication, it should not be affected. I will take everything into consideration and pass the orders,” Justice Rao observed.
Mr. Banerjee’s counsel argued that the threat perception assessed by the state government did not reflect the situation on the ground.
“I do not deny the fact that my client is at risk. I am only asking for an emergency security review of his security and that his security coverage be increased in the meantime,” he said.
“I am grateful for an impartial hearing regardless of what happened. I will advise my client,” he added.
The proceedings ended with the court reserving its ruling on the objection.
After the alleged attack on his residence in south Kolkata’s Kalighat on November 7, a visibly distraught Mr. Banerjee accused a section of the judiciary, among others, of turning a blind eye to threats to his security.
“This is not the first organized attack on me. It started on June 19 when I visited Sonarpur and continued till the day I returned from Delhi. The man who was seen in the photographs with Suvendu Adhikari tried to kill me at the airport with a gun. I lodged a complaint but no action was taken against the accused,” claimed Mr Banerjee.
“I moved to the high court. The court heard the matter partially. The matter was listed for hearing on the 13th in the court of Justice Krishna Rao. Maybe there was some pressure from these people, due to which the court did not complete the hearing. Later, before the vacation bench started functioning, my motion was listed as point no. 16. The judge heard up to case no. 15,” he claimed that my security motion was in another case row, because another matter was in court.
Mr. Banerjee alleged that the court was maintaining an “uncomfortable silence” on the issue of his security threats.
“We are fighting BJP-backed anarchy, police incompetence, torture of a section of politicians and inexplicable silence of the high court. The court proceedings have been going on for the last three months. I am not worried about my safety, but I wonder if this can happen to MPs, where does the safety of the common man lie,” he said.
Published – November 13, 2026 12:12 PM IST