Karnataka High Court asks authorities to determine nationality of man who claimed to be Indian before deporting him to Bangladesh

The court directed the authorities to take expeditious steps to ascertain the petitioner’s nationality after giving him a reasonable opportunity to present his case. | Photo credit: File Photo

The Karnataka High Court has ordered the authorities not to proceed with the deportation of a person suspected of being an illegal immigrant from Bangladesh without first giving them a fair and reasonable opportunity to prove their claim to Indian citizenship by birth and determine their nationality through due process of law.

Disposing of a writ petition filed by Abdul Rahim, who was confined to the Utile Foundation (UF) in Kothanur, Bengaluru under a movement restriction order issued by the Foreign Regional Registration Officer (FRRO), Judge CM Poonacha directed the authorities to take expeditious steps to ascertain his nationality after giving him a reasonable opportunity to present his case.

The petitioner challenged the FRRO order dated March 5, 2026 directing him to remain in UF pending his repatriation, issued on the ground that he is a Bangladeshi national and that there is a likelihood of him disappearing and indulging in undesirable activities.

However, Mr. Rahim claimed that he was an Indian citizen by birth and had resided in India for several decades. He claimed that he was born in New Seemapuri, Delhi on April 14, 1979 and moved to Bengaluru in 2014 where he was involved in waste management and scrap metal trading through his proprietary concern.

He has relied on several documents to substantiate his claim, including a passport issued in 2018, voter ID card issued in 2005, Aadhaar card, PAN card, driving license and other certificates issued by the government.

Against the petition, the authorities alleged that Mr. Rahim was a Bangladeshi national who had relied on fabricated and fraudulent documents to claim Indian citizenship.

The FRRO also pointed out discrepancies in the birth certificates submitted by him in two different proceedings. He said the hospital where he was said to have been born was only established in December 1995 and therefore could not issue a birth record relating to 1979. Authorities also questioned the authenticity of his father’s death certificate and other documents.

However, the court noted that the authorities should have considered the various documents relied on by the petitioner and given him an opportunity to prove his citizenship before issuing the restraining order.

Earlier case in UP

Although the petitioner was convicted by a court in Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh in 2010 under Section 14A(b) of the Aliens Act, 1946 for illegal entry into India, Justice Poonacha noted that the Allahabad High Court later granted him bail and that all these materials were not taken into account by the FRRO while passing the order to deport him.

The court clarified that possession of such documents alone does not conclusively establish Indian citizenship. However, the authorities could not ignore them without conducting a proper review.

Section 16 of the Immigration and Foreigners Order 2025, the court pointed out, contains provision for referring the question of whether a person is a foreigner to the Aliens Tribunal.

However, the court declined to determine Mr. Rahim’s citizenship for the first time in the trial, leaving the matter to be decided by the relevant authorities through the prescribed legal process.

Published – 16 Nov 2026 21:13 IST