Collective Batting Surrender! How the mighty fell in New Zealand

Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma Mount Maunganui: “Not anymore… we’ve just settled in,” said a group of fans on the grassy banks, enjoying the afternoon sun, before another set called out, “even the fizz of the beer is still alive.” There was collective exasperation when Rohit Sharma dragged himself back to the dressing room after another poor outing in New Zealand. It must have been deja vu for repeat spectators at the Bay Oval; they saw the former captain released early within three days.For more than a decade now, Indian cricket has witnessed a trend: the first wicket creates cheers with the arrival of Virat Kohli increasing anticipation and excitement. But in this five-match ODI series, even those jubilations were short-lived and that feeling quickly turned to disappointment. And then embarrassment.It was the story of the ODI part of the tour. Batting techniques were exposed, shot selection was questioned and players did not stay in the middle long enough.The build-up to the series was dominated by an inexperienced bowling attack, but as the curtain came down on the five-ODI affair, it turned to India’s illustrious line-up in meek capitulation. The conditions were testing, the weather unpredictable and the opposition attack hostile. But it was disturbing to see how the batting folded.For the first time since 1985, no Indian batsman has managed to score 100 runs in a five-ODI series. Virat Kohli’s chart-topping 86 and 74 of those runs came in the series opener in Auckland. This knock was also the only fifty-plus score by Indian batsmen in the four ODIs they played. Not just Rohit and Kohli, even Shreyas Iyer and Axar Patel struggled to go. Shubman Gill also scored 37 runs (in 2 innings) before focusing on Test series preparations in Wellington.For the most part, the underlying theme of the series has remained that these conditions are the closest to what would be expected in South Africa at the World Cup. Performances give little confidence and head coach Gautam Gambhir’s assessment after the fourth ODI suggested alarm bells were ringing.“It always worries you when you get bundled up at 90-odd. Why shouldn’t I worry?” Gambhir said at the post-match press conference. “I think I will be concerned because obviously those are the conditions that will be closest to what we might get during the World Cup.”

India’s Rohit Sharma plays a shot during the One Day International cricket match between New Zealand and India in Tauranga, New Zealand. AP/PTI(AP11_15_2026_000096A)

“Obviously when you play in India, you all know there’s almost nothing for the bowlers, but when you come into these conditions you know there’s actually a good match between bat and ball, so this is probably the closest, so of course I’d be worried because not only in this game, but even in the previous game, we were down by 7 at 111-112, so I think it’s going to go quickly – I don’t think it’s a big problem. 26 or 27 overs, so hopefully we’ll try to rectify that as soon as possible.”Gambhir’s hopes of a turnaround in the final went up in smoke when a similar scenario unfolded at the Bay Oval, even as he batted first with the sun in full glory. More than the pitch playing tricks or the pitchers being unplayable, the issue was the cautious approach and questionable shot selections. Rohit went for early swing, Kohli played a rash shot, Ruturaj Gaikwad looked good but perished in the drive and Shreyas Iyer again went for the short ball.

Indian captain Shreyas Iyer plays a shot during the One Day International cricket match between New Zealand and India in Tauranga, New Zealand. AP/PTI

It has been collective batting, and while the series against Sri Lanka and Zimbabwe will bring them back among the runs, weaknesses away from home will need some serious introspection. For starters, the team management must aim for lively pitches in the six ODIs preceding the IPL, as flat tracks serve no purpose other than to inflate the averages and induce false optimism.“Kya hi hoga inka World Cup mai? (what will happen to them during the World Cup?)… inko highway pe hi khilao (let them play only on level pitches),” was the mood on the lawns behind the stadium. The Indian fans who turned up in large numbers did not have good memories to take home but offered a collective warning to avoid awakening the ghosts of the past.Quick Score: India 209 in 42.1 overs (Axar Patel 46, Ishan Kishan 46; Mitchell Santner 3/47, Jacob Duffy 3/60) beat New Zealand 187 in 48.1 overs (Dean Foxcroft 31; Arshdeep Singh 3/30) by 22 runs.