Central Secretariat Library relocation line: SC stops center; suspends the transfer of 8.5 million books | What we know | Today’s news

For book lovers, a library is much more than a room full of shelves. It serves as a repository of knowledge, history and ideas, offering readers a space to explore, learn and discover. The Supreme Court’s recent remarks on the transfer of nearly 8.5 million books from the Central Secretariat library have renewed attention on the importance of preserving such collections.

The Supreme Court on Monday adjourned the matter regarding the relocation of the 135-year-old library of the Central Secretariat (ČSL) until Friday. He also ordered that books stored in the library should not be moved in the meantime, LiveLaw reported.

Read also | The SC will hear a suo motu case on the relocation of the Central Secretariat library on Monday

Justice Sanjay Kumar expressed concern over the manner in which books worth 8.5 crore were being disposed of and accused the Center of adopting an ad hoc approach to preserve the library’s heritage.

The Supreme Court remarked: “You’re just in a hurry to do it. What are you planning to do with these books? There seems to be an ad hoc approach. You’re not bothered…this is some heritage. Basically, the heritage for us goes back to 1702. If you don’t want them, give them to another country that will appreciate them…Show these two books some respect.”

Case background

The hearing comes after the apex court took suo motu cognizance of the lack of space allotted to CSL, which currently houses 8.5 lakh books, under the Central Vista plan. In early October, the court sought an affidavit detailing the space allocated to the library and its layout.

The Supreme Court’s intervention was sought on October 3 after reports suggested that the library, currently located at Shastri Bhawan, could face relocation in view of the proposed demolition of the building as part of the redevelopment plan. Questions have been raised as to whether suitable space can be secured for the 135-year-old library and how its extensive holdings will be secured during the move.

The Indian Express reported in October that CSL, currently spread over four floors, faces uncertainty as the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA) has allotted only two rooms for it in the Kartavya Bhawan-2 complex as part of a redevelopment plan.

The MoHUA has directed all ministries to vacate Shastri Bhawan by the end of September to pave the way for its demolition and redevelopment, the release added.

Read also | ‘Central Vista’ now ‘Kartavya Bhawan Area’: Manohar Lal

What happened during the Supreme Court proceedings?

When the matter came up for hearing, a two-judge bench comprising Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdev was informed that the Center had filed an affidavit. Although the affidavit was not recorded, senior advocate amicus curiae Haripriya Padmanabhan told the court that efforts are being made to expedite the transfer of books of accounts by November. She urged the court to stop the move and asked the center for more clarity on the space available at the proposed new site.

“I would like them to state how much is currently being used for libraries and compare that to how much is being used at the new site,” she told the court.

Padmanabhan also raised concerns about some of the books kept at RK Puram. She said she visited the site and found it in a “terrible state”. According to her, the books have remained in this condition for the past 15 years and were part of the original collection of the library. Her submissions drew strong oral arguments from the court.

The Supreme Court then asked the Additional Solicitor General about the urgency of moving the books and directed the Centre, “So you will not move the books.”

The court issued an order stating: “ASG says the books will not be moved until the next meeting. Dated November 20. In the meantime, the affidavit to be filed today will be recorded.”

Similar Posts