Captain Pat Cummins, Personal Brand May Not Survive Sandpapergate: Ex-pacer
Former Australian fast bowler Mitchell Johnson believes it could be difficult for Pat Cummins to retain his Test captaincy following new revelations surrounding the infamous Sandpapergate scandal. Johnson feels the public pressure on the Australian captain to step down will be too much and doubts whether his leadership and personal brand can survive the controversy.
The latest development came after Cameron Bancroft, who was caught using sandpaper on the ball during the 2018 Cape Town Test against South Africa, made explosive statements about the incident.
In a 4,000-word account published in The West Australian, Bancroft argued that the whole team knew about the use of the facility and that the responsibility did not lie solely with him, Steve Smith and David Warner, who were punished after the scandal.
Johnson, writing in The West Australian, said he believed Bancroft’s account and felt the former Australian opener had nothing to lose by speaking out.
“I believe Bancroft’s account. It feels real to me and I felt the words when he said them. He came in as himself and now he has nothing to lose. It also matches the most detailed accounts we’ve heard from other players,” Johnson wrote.
“The pressure on Cummins is huge now. I think he will still try to stand by what he said and his statement with all the bowlers in 2021.
“But I think the public pressure on Cummins to step down as Test captain now will be too much. I just don’t see how his captaincy and personal brand will survive that.”
CUMMINS FACES ASSEMBLY PRESSURE
Cummins faced questions about his involvement after former Australian batsman Usman Khawaja made similar claims in his autobiography. However, the Australian captain vehemently denied the allegations during a lengthy press conference last week, insisting he had no knowledge of sandpaper being brought onto the pitch.
“When he says we all knew, if he means we knew there was sandpaper on the field, he’s 100 percent wrong. I’ve been saying that consistently for the last eight years. I didn’t know it was happening,” Cummins said.
He also called Khawaja’s claim that he and others were the architects of the ball-tampering plan “complete and utter nonsense”.
The captain’s stance was echoed by Cummins manager Neil Maxwell on Thursday, saying his “position has not changed in eight years.”
Johnson, meanwhile, believes the controversy has seriously affected the standing of Cummins and Australia’s senior bowling group, including Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon.
“Seems like support for Cummins and Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon and their version of events is now at its lowest point. And all this is already affecting our summer of cricket,” Johnson wrote.
The original Sandpapergate scandal erupted during Australia’s 2018 tour of South Africa when Bancroft was caught attempting to alter the condition of the ball. With new reports casting doubt on the version of events presented eight years ago, the controversy has once again become a major issue in Australian cricket.
Cricket Australia said the independent forum would give those involved the opportunity to share their accounts, although the original investigation would not be reopened. The challenge for Cummins now is to navigate renewed scrutiny while continuing to lead Australia through their home summer.
– The end