Why do judges recede from suo motu cases? Decoded when the Central Sec Library case reaches CJI in the middle of the SC breakdown line | Today’s news

A two-judge bench of the Supreme Court hearing a suo motu case related to the proposed relocation of the Central Secretariat Library (CSL) in Delhi on Friday refused to proceed with the matter. The Bench said the case will now be placed before the Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant for listing before the appropriate Bench, Bar and Bench Committee.

The case pertains to the 135-year-old CSL at Shastri Bhawan, which is proposed to be relocated as part of the Central Vista redevelopment plan to allegedly two rooms in the Kartavya Bhawan-2 complex. Housed in Shastri Bhawan since 1969, the library is currently spread over four floors. However, its future remains uncertain as no adequate measures have been taken to maintain its approximately 8.5 million books.

Read also | Central Secretariat Library row: SC suspends movement of 8.5 million books

What did the two judge Bench say?

On Friday, a two-judge bench comprising Justices PV Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdev said it was recusing itself from the case, citing the recent rulings of CJI Surya Kant. The CJI said that PIL cases pending before Benches which do not have jurisdiction to hear them will be reassigned in accordance with the judicial list.

The Bench observed that though the CJI’s office was informed that it had taken over the matter, it had no jurisdiction to hear the matter. Consequently, the case was referred to the CJI.

Justice Kumar said, “Therefore let the matter be referred to the CJI for listing before the appropriate court.” The Bench also indirectly referred to the withdrawal of some cases from the Bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah. Justice Kumar added: “Let’s follow the procedure. You know what happened recently.”

The bench further said that although the suo motu case relating to the Central Secretariat Library could potentially be reassigned to it, it would not hear the matter until the CJI decides on its assignment.

Why was the case handed over to the CJI?

The development comes amid controversy over CJI Surya Kant’s reallocation of cases. The CJI recently ordered the transfer of certain cases from Benches that did not have jurisdiction to hear PILs as per the Supreme Court list.

The move followed concerns that Benches were turning individual disputes into wider public interest trials. According to the Bar and Bench, the CJI has also asked the Supreme Court Registry to identify such cases and ensure that they are assigned to appropriate Benches.

Read also | The SC will hear a suo motu case on the relocation of the Central Secretariat library on Monday

According to the Supreme Court’s list, PILs are assigned exclusively to benches headed by seven senior judges. They include CJI Surya Kant and Justices Vikram Nath, BV Nagarathna, MM Sundresh, PS Narasimha, JB Pardiwala and Dipankar Datta.

The CJI’s role as “master of the list” gives him the administrative power to allocate cases and decide which benches will hear them.

In this connection, the case of the Secretariat’s Central Library has also been referred to the CJI, who will decide which committee is suitable to hear the matter.

The Central Secretariat Library Relocation Case: What We Know

The bench initiated the suo motu proceedings after The Indian Express published a report in October that highlighted concerns over the proposed relocation of the library and the lack of adequate provision at the new location.

The library, which comes under the Union Ministry of Culture, was originally established as the Imperial Secretariat Library in Calcutta in 1891. Later it was shifted to Delhi and since 1969 it is located in Shastri Bhawan. Its collection includes more than 8,500 volumes, including rare books, government publications, official documents and gazettes.

As the Shastri Bhawan building is slated for demolition, the Ministry of Culture has requested around 5,466 square meters of space for a library in the redeveloped Central Secretariat.

However, the Directorate of Estates under the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA) has proposed to allot only two rooms measuring around 300 square meters at Kartavya Bhawan-2 to the library.

In February, the Ministry of Culture told MoHUA that the proposed space would not be sufficient to accommodate the entire collection and library facilities, so a complete move to the allocated space was not possible.

Amid concerns over the preservation and future of the books, the Supreme Court took suo motu cognizance of the matter after it was brought to the court’s attention by some retired judges.

Read also | The Center is challenging the Yes Bank AT-1 bond decision in the Supreme Court

During the November 16 hearing, the Center assured the Supreme Court that the books would not be moved before the next hearing scheduled for November 20. The court also expressed concern over the proposed transfer arrangement and said the government must show more respect to the books.

As the matter is now referred to CJI Surya Kant, the next step will be to determine which bench will hear the case and consider the concerns related to the proposed relocation of the library.

Similar Posts