Supreme Court permits lighting of lamp at deepathoon in Thirupparankundram as limited one time arrangement
The Supreme Court on Friday (November 20, 2026) allowed lamp lighting as a ‘limited one-off arrangement’ on deepathoonat Thirupparankundram Hill in Madurai district of Tamil Nadu on Karthigai Deepam day (November 24).
However, a bench headed by Justice Aravind Kumar stuck to the final findings of the Madras High Court in its January 6 judgment, which upheld the right to light a lamp on deepathoon as a basic procedure. The court issued a notice of appeals filed by the state.
The interim order dealt with the state’s pleas to stay the January 6 judgment and examined the question of whether a lamp could be lit at the deepathoon on the upcoming Karthigai Deepam day.
Deepathoon (stone lamp pillar) is about 50 meters from Sikandar Badusha Dargah. While the dargah is on top of the hill, the Subramaniya Swamy temple is at the foot of the hill. The court’s interim arrangement comes amid a dispute between Hindu worshipers and the dargah over ownership of the hilltop and deepathoon site
“What weighs upon us at this stage is the peculiar nature of the occasion and the proximity of the festival to be held on November 24. The opportunity to perform the ceremony on that particular day, if denied, cannot be restored by any subsequent decision. We are equally aware that a ceremony once permitted cannot be taken back,” the order said.
A bench comprising Justice PB Varale said there was a need to balance the immediacy of the festival with the need to ensure that the interim order does not vitiate the state’s appeal or become fodder for vested rights claims. “We are of the view that a limited, one-time arrangement subject to strict safeguards would properly balance the interests at stake pending further consideration,” the court said.
The court imposed a number of restrictions and safeguards and ordered that the Subramaniya Swamy Devasthanam temple exclusively decide to light the lamp on November 24 by team members only. He directed that the composition and number of the team will be determined by the Collector of Madurai in consultation with the Executive Officer of the Temple, Archaeological Survey of India and the Commissioner of Police, Madurai. The Collector will act as the Nodal Officer for the event. The security perimeter has to be provided by the Madurai City Police Commissioner. The center has been directed to augment security arrangements with CRPF personnel if required.
The bench banned any kind of procession, public assembly, demonstration, slogan-raising or any activity other than the ceremonial lighting of the lamp at the site.
The free space given on November 24 should not be interpreted as a judicial recognition of a basic religious practice, the court emphasized repeatedly. “We make it abundantly clear that this stipulation is not predicated on any finding that the stone pillar is or historically has been the site of a customary religious ceremony. Nor does it determine whether the lighting of a lamp at the site constitutes a fundamental religious practice, or whether any individual, religious denomination or institution has an enforceable right in that regard.” All questions of title, possession, customary use, religious right and right are expressly underlined.
Only authorized persons would be allowed access to the lamp lighting. The team would leave the ‘deepathoon’ site immediately after lighting the lamp without leaving behind any temporary or permanent installation or objects, the court ordered. There would be no damage or alteration to any religious monument, including the nearby hilltop dargah, the interim order said, adding that worshipers’ access and enjoyment of the dargah should not be disturbed.
The court has repeatedly made it clear that this preliminary injunction does not give anyone any binding, enforceable right or claim. The interim arrangement for November 24 should not be shown as a precedent for claiming similar permission in any subsequent year.
“Neither the permission granted by this court, nor the performance of a ceremony thereunder, may be relied upon by any party as evidence of established custom, precedent of religious custom, title, right of access, or alteration of existing legal status pending the determination of these appeals,” the court clarified.
Justice Kumar said the issues raised by the state remained open for decision. “Questions regarding the nature of the alleged custom, the legal character of the disputed website, the rights arising from earlier decrees and the statutory body of the institutions concerned will be assessed at the appropriate stage,” the court said.
Observance of religious rights among different faiths must be based on mutual respect, the court noted.
The court directed the Collector to file a status report within three days of the incident. In the second week of January 2027, the case was brought up for further hearing.
State the steps you plan to take: Stalin
DMK president MK Stalin said Chief Minister C. Joseph Vijay must explain the legal steps the TVK-led government plans to take next. He recalled that the previous DMK government in Tamil Nadu fought hard to “maintain peace and communal harmony”.
CPI(M) state secretary P. Shanmugam said that allowing a lamp to be lit, even this year, in a place where it had never been lit before was unfair. “The state government must immediately file a review petition against this verdict. It must also take appropriate measures to vigorously counter the communal forces trying to create tension and thereby protect social peace and harmony,” he said in a statement.
Calling the verdict shocking, CPI state secretary M. Veerapandian said the Supreme Court should reconsider and set aside the verdict. He also invited the state to file a motion for review.
‘Dharma’ Won: Nagenthran
BJP State President Nainar Nagenthran welcomed the decision. Talking to reporters in Tirunelveli, he said that ‘dharma’ had won. He accused the ruling TVK and the opposition DMK of creating obstacles. “It is so painful to see how DMK and TVK are creating legal hurdles to light ‘deepam’ on top of a pillar. While the constitution guarantees Indian citizens their right to practice the faith of their choice, the Hindu Religious and Charitable Department, which should always protect Hindu temples and their festivals, is spending millions of rupees and lighting their lawsuits as welfare in court.” ‘deepam’ on Karthigai Deepam day,” he said.
Published – 20 Nov 2026 14:29 IST