NYC Fitness Buffs Bristle at City Plan to Close Outdoor Gym | Today’s news
(Bloomberg) — Even pull-down bars have become a flashpoint in New York City’s neighborhood-level disputes over government projects.
In Manhattan’s Tompkins Square Park, the paint is peeling off the bars. But fitness enthusiasts who exercise daily in the park cling to them for dear life.
The city’s proposals to close an outdoor gym for months and replace it with equipment that is more accessible to people with disabilities are controversial.
Regulars argue that the facility is affordable enough that the city could renovate it from inferior materials. Some simply dread the month-long separation from the bars that have become part of their daily lives.
For Theophilus London, the stakes are particularly personal. About three months ago, struggling and wanting to change his life, he found his way to the bars in Tompkins Square Park.
“I was in desperate need of a lifestyle change,” London said between sets in an East Village park on a recent afternoon. “This park has changed my life.
London, a 2016 Grammy-nominated musician alongside Kanye West, hits the bars daily. He is one of many park-goers speaking out against plans to close the decades-old fitness facility for renovations.
The park joins a list of government projects that some New Yorkers have seen as community intrusion.
A few blocks to the southwest in Nolita, residents have protested construction of an affordable housing project at Elizabeth Street Garden for more than a decade. Plans to build a skate park in Mount Prospect Park across Brooklyn’s East River have been the subject of neighborhood groups who said the facility would exacerbate the problem of warmer temperatures in urban areas.
“The idea that this is an adult fitness center that needs renovation is completely and utterly wrong,” said Salo Coslovsky, a professor of urban planning at New York University, at a recent meeting of a local advisory board on Tompkins Square Park’s pull-up bars.
Coslovsky questioned the expertise of the consultants working on the project. “I don’t know if they’re really doing push-ups and dips,” he said, adding that thousands of people who signed an online petition against the renovations disagreed with the consultants’ assessment. It now has roughly 3,700 signatures.
The improvements to the park would see the reconstruction of the basketball courts and the doubling of the size of the park’s swimming pool. The project received $6.1 million from New York Gov. Kathy Hochul through an initiative to improve public swimming facilities and an additional $2.8 million from Mayor Zohran Mamdani, according to city records.
Department of Parks and Recreation Commissioner Tricia Shimamura said in a statement that she was committed to making the parks more accessible and that her department was working to reduce the amount of time the exercise facility would be closed.
The city gathers input from residents, including by sending park planners to neighborhood advisory board meetings. The meetings took a long time to accommodate public comments from people who say closing the bars would be a serious mistake.
Jahmal Kirwan is part of a larger group with London who practice in bars. A lifelong resident of Lower Manhattan, Kirwan said he’s not opposed to improving the park.
About two years ago, he said, the bars and the community around them helped him recover from the “death zone” of drinking and partying every day. He fears the city could delay the renovations, as well as other nearby structures, leaving the community without a meeting place for too long as it waits for the finished product.
Kirwan said he hadn’t attended a local advisory board meeting in his life until he heard about the impending closure of the pull-up bars. Over the past few months, he has attended to voice his concerns.
“It’s like they shut down rehab,” Kirwan said. Regarding the city’s proposal to close the bars for about 18 months, he said: “There will be people who will never see the bars because they might not even survive.
More such stories are available at bloomberg.com