Bihar doctor fined ₹30,000 for leaving surgical gauze in abdomen during gallbladder surgery
The Bihar Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission on Wednesday (Nov 18, 2026) ordered a doctor found guilty of gross negligence for leaving surgical gauze (cotton swabs) in a patient’s abdomen during a routine gall bladder operation to pay ₹30 crore as compensation.
The case relates to the late Nibha Singh (53), wife of Mani Kant Singh, a resident of Madhepura in Bihar. After complaining of abdominal pain, the deceased turned to Dr. Rajesh Kumar Singh (Opposite Party No. 1), laparoscopic surgeon at Gayatri Nursing Home, Saharsa.
On March 19, 2016, she underwent an operation to remove the gallbladder on the doctor’s recommendation. After the operation, her health began to deteriorate rapidly; she suffered from severe abdominal pain, vomiting and intestinal obstruction.
Although she was examined by several doctors and hospitals, the root cause of her condition remained unknown. She was then admitted to Sir Ganga Ram Hospital in New Delhi where doctors performed an emergency operation (laparotomy).
During the procedure, a large, blood-soaked surgical gauze (fungus) measuring 15x4x3 cm was discovered in her abdomen, which caused the infection (peritonitis) to spread throughout the abdominal cavity.
Despite medical intervention, the patient died on July 1, 2016 — just hours after being discharged from the hospital — due to serious complications and subsequent infection.
The bench included Chief Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Md Shamim Akhtar. Citing previous decisions of the Supreme Court and the National Commission, Mr. Akhtar clarified that leaving surgical materials or gauze in a patient’s abdomen during surgery clearly falls under the category of “gross negligence”.
In its regulation, the Commission stated that it is the primary responsibility of the physician and their surgical team to account for all surgical instruments and gauze prior to closing the incision; failure to do so in this case will seriously endanger the life of the patient.
The commission ordered the primary erring doctor (Respondent No. 1) to pay the injured husband a sum of ₹ 30,00,000 (Rupees thirty lakh) as compensation along with ₹ 20,000 towards court costs within 60 days of receiving the order.
“If payment is not made within the specified time frame, interest will accrue at the rate of 8% per annum. Counterparty #1 failed to act when the patient repeatedly visited with complaints of severe abdominal pain and distension and should have prompted an early examination using appropriate imaging methods, instead Counterparty #1 recommended prescribing symptomatic medication and failed to diagnose the actual cause of the pain and failed to diagnose the actual cause of the pain
The commission further stated: “Opposite No. 1 failed to compile safety checklists, especially where the patient shows signs of post-operative complications. There was a clinical discrepancy in the ultrasound report and the health status of the complainant’s wife. Opponent No. 1 failed to diagnose the cause of the patient’s suffering and pain, which he could have easily diagnosed if he had been more careful and cautious.”
The resolution also pointed out that the doctor did not use reasonable skill and competence in treating the applicant’s wife. He did not meet the reasonable standard of care expected of a medical professional.
Published – 18 Nov 2026 22:58 IST