‘Meaningless game’: Magnus Carlsen sparks controversy, loses matches against Bibisara Assaubayeva on back-to-back days

Magnus Carlsen and Bibisara Assaubayeva (Image credit: X) World No. 1 Magnus Carlsen has been embroiled in controversy at the Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot after losing his Fast Classic games against Bibisara Assaubayeva on two consecutive days.The Norwegian left the board after building an unstoppable lead in the tie. However, he did not inform his opponent, who remained waiting for him at the venue. Carlsen spoke to the referee before leaving.Carlsen was already out of contention for the title and was playing for 17th place. On Tuesday, he built an 11-point lead by winning three of four blitzes and two quick games against Bibisara. He did the same on Wednesday after scoring 10 points on four blitzes and two rushing plays.Bibisara won all eight available points over both days after Carlsen lost classic games. Nevertheless, the Norwegian won the tie. He won the match 11.5-8.5 on the first day, while the second day ended in a 10-10 draw.

Magnus Carlsen explains why he lost games

Carlsen defended his decision, saying there was no reason to play a classic game once the outcome of the tie had been decided.“There will be no classic game as I understand it, the match is over. The only consequence of not showing up is that you lose a completely meaningless game,” Carlsen said on Tuesday, according to Norwegian TV2.“I think when you play the World Cup and it counts for points and stuff, I understand that.The decision also came at a difficult time for Carlsen’s rating. A draw or loss in the Fast Classic would drop him below the 2800 Elo mark for the first time in nearly 17 years. Since 2009, it has been above the limit.Carlsen had problems in the Fast Classic format in the Budapest pilot. Finished fifth in their group after recording nine draws and one defeat in 10 matches. His only loss came against Armenia’s Haik Martirosyan.The Norwegian also lost 21.8 rating points in the last week. Now he may be in danger of losing the world number one, which he has held for more than 15 years.Carlsen also expressed his reluctance to play another classic game in the classification match earlier on Tuesday.“It’s an uncomfortable situation, I’d rather not play that much more classic,” he said.

Total Chess to review the format after the Budapest pilot

Total Chess CEO Kjell Madland said the Budapest pilot project will help organizers understand how the format works in real competition. They will consider changes if necessary before the first release in March 2027.“The Budapest pilot is an important learning exercise for Total Chess. While we have developed the format and rules with considerable thought and input, the real test is how they perform in a live competitive environment.”“We want to hear directly from players and referees, understand their experiences and take constructive feedback.“Our goal is to assess whether any improvements are necessary before the inaugural edition in March 2027. We are not approaching this with a preconceived notion that the rules need to be changed; rather, we want to make sure we have thoroughly tested the format and introduced the best possible version of it by the inaugural season,” Madland said in a statement.Organizers could not immediately confirm whether Carlsen would face an automatic penalty for forfeiting the Games.