Magnus Carlsen loses matches against Bibisara, sparking controversy in Total Chess

World No.1 Magnus Carlsen found himself at the center of controversy at the Total Chess World Championship Tour Pilot after losing his Fast Classic games against Bibisara Assaubayev on both days of their two-day match.

Carlsen left the playing hall after taking the lead in a tie, leaving Bibisara to wait for him. The Norwegian spoke to the referee before leaving, but did not inform his opponent of his decision.

After fighting for the title and playing for 17th place, Carlsen built an 11-point lead on Tuesday by winning three of four blitz games and two quick games against Bibisara.

He repeated that decision Wednesday after scoring 10 points on four blitzes and two rushing plays.

Bibisara was awarded all eight points on offer over both days. However, the tie was still won by Carlsen, winning the match 11.5-8.5 on the opening day, before ending the second day in a 10-10 draw.

Carlsen defended his decision, saying there was no point playing a classic game once the result was decided.

“There will be no classic game as I understand it, the match is over. The only consequence of not showing up is that you lose a completely meaningless game,” Carlsen said on Tuesday, according to Norwegian TV2.

“I think when you play the World Cup and it counts for points and stuff, I understand that.

His decision came at a time when his ratings were also under pressure. A draw or loss in the Fast Classic would drop Carlsen below the 2800 Elo mark for the first time in nearly 17 years. Nor has been above 2,800 since 2009.

Carlsen had problems in the Fast Classic format in the Budapest pilot. Finished fifth in their group after managing nine draws and one defeat against Haik Martirosyan’s Armenia in 10 matches. It lost 21.8 rating points in the last week.

The Norwegian could also be in danger of losing his world number one ranking, which he has held for more than 15 years.

Earlier on Tuesday, Carlsen made it clear that he was not interested in playing another classic game in the classification match.

“It’s an uncomfortable situation, I’d rather not play that much more classic,” he said.

TOTAL CHESS ON CHECK FORMAT AFTER BUDAPEST

Total Chess CEO Kjell Madland said the Budapest pilot project will help organizers assess the format and make changes if necessary ahead of the inaugural edition in March 2027.

“The Budapest pilot is an important learning exercise for Total Chess. While we have developed the format and rules with considerable thought and input, the real test is how they perform in a live competitive environment.”

“We want to hear directly from players and referees, understand their experiences and take constructive feedback.

“Our goal is to assess whether any improvements are necessary before the inaugural edition in March 2027. We are not approaching this with a preconceived notion that the rules need to be changed; rather, we want to make sure we have thoroughly tested the format and introduced the best possible version of it by the inaugural season,” Madland said in a statement.

Organizers could not immediately confirm whether Carlsen would face an automatic penalty for forfeiting the Games.

NIEMANN ACCUSES THE ORGANIZERS OF FAVORITISM

Carlsen’s decision drew criticism from American Grandmaster Hans Niemann, who is also competing at the event. Niemann accused the organizers of giving Norwegian preferential treatment and questioned whether another player would have been given the same freedom.

“Whether plays can be counted after the match is over was discussed and agreed at the technical meeting. If Carlsen had played someone with a higher rating, he might have been more inclined to play.”

“However, if any other player had lost the game, disrespected the organizer and his opponent, he would have lost the match by forfeit. It is extremely disappointing to see the continued favoritism of one player. Let’s not forget the jeans and the ‘Co World Champion’ saga. All rules must apply equally, regardless of the player. End of story,” Niemann wrote on X.

Carlsen’s actions were also criticized by FIDE’s executive advisor Emil Šutovský. “Hard to comment on such poor unsportsmanlike conduct,” he wrote.

India’s Olympic chess captain Srinath Narayanan also took a look at Nora and wrote on X: “Dignity and civility fell long before the assessment.”

– The end