Thirupparankundram row: TN government pushes for stay of HC order to prevent breach of peace

Senior advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan, appearing for the Madurai District Collector, said the word “Deepathoon” “never came into being before 2025”.

The Tamil Nadu government on Tuesday urged the Supreme Court to stay the Madras High Court’s January 2026 decision that upheld its earlier order to the Arulmigu Subramaniswamy devasthanam or governing body to light the Karthigai Deepam on a stone pillar located atop the Thirupparankundram hill.

A Division Bench of the High Court in January upheld the earlier order of a single judge, brushing aside concerns expressed by the state that such a move would be a sure recipe for “disturbance of public peace and tranquility”, given the fact that the stone pillar was near a dargah. The Supreme Court dismissed these concerns as an “imaginary ghost”.

On Tuesday, senior advocate Shekhar Naphade of the Tamil Nadu government said the fear is very real and the status quo must remain until the Supreme Court makes a final decision on the state’s appeal against the January order.

The submission came in over an hour-long hearing before Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi. The hearing will continue on November 18.

Senior advocate Jaideep Gupta of the state department’s Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) commissioner argued that the baseless allegations of the Hindu Dharma Parishad (which was the petitioner in the Supreme Court) about the “custom” of lighting the Karthigai depam on Deepathoon was a “sensitive violation of the recorded history of peace”. communal tension”.

Mr. Gupta along with Additional Solicitor General of Tamil Nadu and Senior Advocate Prashanto Chandra Sen said that there was never any established practice, custom or even previous claim of lighting Karthigai Deepam on top of Thirupparankundram hill or on the stone pillar “now described as Deepathoon”. They stated that the Karthigai Deepam was lit only in the Deepa Mandapam for more than 150 years.

“So it doesn’t matter what the custom is, what the Sthanikars think… anything can be done now… Is there any custom that the petitioner has established that would entitle him to allow himself to light a lamp on a pillar or order a Devasthanam to light it on top of a hill? If the petitioner claims such a right, the onus is on him (the parish),” Mr. Gupta said.

Mr. Naphade said the petitioner wanted to light the lamp on the dargah side and not on the temple side.

“He wants to light the lamp on the right side. On the right side is the dargah and on the left side is the temple. Natural division. As a result of the Supreme Court order, the natural division would be disturbed. There is potential for disturbing public peace,” Mr Naphade said.

Mr. Sen argued that the Supreme Court cannot direct the temple executive to make innovations regarding time and place of worship or performance of rituals that would affect the established rights and facilities of worshippers.

Senior advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan, appearing for the Madurai District Collector, said the word “Deepathoon” “never came into being before 2025”.

He said the petitioner’s entire prayer before the Supreme Court was that “there is a pillar. In my imagination, this pillar is a religious place and ‘I want you, the court, to come in and let me light a lamp there'”.

A recent affidavit filed by the HR&CE department in the high court said that the conduct of daily poojas, festivals and observance of the usual rituals of the temple, including the manner and place of lighting the Karthigai Deepam, falls within the exclusive domain of the temple administration in accordance with the Agamas, the view of the Sthanikars Act-Act-Parish and any private association such as the 1959 parish association.

He stated that the ownership of the hill near the temple had already been decreed and settled by a court order of 1923. According to which the temple owned and possessed the entire hill and the Giri Veedhi (surrounding road) except certain areas such as the assessed and occupied land at Nellithope, the steps leading to the mosque and the top of the rock on which the mosque and the banner of the Muslims stood.

Published – 18 Nov 2026 0:40 AM IST