No mechanism to check whether an arbitrator is fit enough, says Madras HC Justice Anand Venkatesh

Justice N. Anand Venkatesh, Judge, Madras High Court. | Photo credit: FILE PHOTO

Justice N. Anand Venkatesh, a judge of the Madras High Court, said there was no mechanism to ensure that an arbitrator was fit enough. Arbitration requires a “completely different mindset” and even High Court or Supreme Court judges would require training on arbitration, he said on Tuesday while speaking at the “Online Dispute Resolution Summit: Technology and Institutional Arbitration” organized by Presolv360.

“Today, there is no mechanism to confirm that this judge is suitable enough for this role. If he is not doing his job, where is the mechanism to take him to task? For a judge who comes from the district judiciary, there is a mechanism. For a judge of the High Court, yes, there is not much of a mechanism, but there is something called a transfer. But at least you will be able to take such a mechanism away from him, and there is, sir.” said Venkatesh.

If there was an “intelligent, corrupt arbitrator”, that was “the end of the matter” and could not be challenged, he said. The judge went on to say, “There has to be a mechanism where the courts will have to accredit arbitrators”. He called for quality arbitrators who were of integrity and honesty and were able to understand the dispute.

Former Punjab and Haryana High Court Judge K. Kannan said all stakeholders along with mediation institutions and lawyers need to create a common framework to ensure resolution of the large number of disputes. “We need standardized protocols. It is necessary. It cannot be that the protocol has some way of doing things with certain institutions. We need standard protocols for referral, mediation, arbitration, settlement, documentation, quality assurance system and grievance mechanisms,” he said.

During his speech, former Union Law Secretary TK Viswanathan recalled that he had drafted several laws. For effective reforms in the law, Mr. Viswanathan suggested that every ministry should submit data to Parliament about how the law is working during its annual budget. Funds could be allocated so that law schools could study “law in action”, he said.

Pointing out that without empirical data, law reforms would be blind, Mr. Viswanathan said, “Law reform today depends on the accidents of litigation and is not scientific”.

“Without data, how can you tell if a law is successful or not?” he asked. The Information Technology Act, 2000, now needs to be revised because of artificial intelligence, which posed major challenges, Mr. Viswanathan added.

Published – 18 Nov 2026 0:02 IST