Sandpapergate: Cricket Australia ready to hear all sides but won’t re-investigate

Cricket Australia has decided not to reopen its investigation into the 2018 ball-tampering scandal, but will set up an independent forum for players and support staff involved in the infamous Cape Town Test to share their accounts of what happened.

The forum will provide an intimate environment for those who wish to come forward and offer their memories of the events that brought Australian cricket to its knees. Cricket Australia (CA) said participation would be voluntary and stressed that the process was not intended to reopen the original investigation, impose new sanctions or review the punishments handed down to Steve Smith, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft.

The decision comes after a a new wave of controversy surrounding Sandpapergateprompted by a revelation in former Australian batsman Usman Khawaja’s autobiography, Sabr. His account of the 2018 tour of South Africa reopened questions about how much the wider Australian team knew about the ball-tampering plan.

CA chairman David Boon said the board believed the forum offered the best opportunity for those involved to be heard while allowing Australian cricket to move forward.

“For nearly a decade, the fallout from these events has remained part of the conversation about Australian cricket. It’s been a difficult chapter for many people and increasingly the ongoing debate has become a distraction from the game. We believe it’s time for a circuit breaker,” Boon said.

“This forum is not about a relic of the past. It is about creating an opportunity for those who want to be heard to tell their stories in a respectful environment and for our sport to listen.”

Then a renewed debate began Khawaja wrote in Sabr that he knew about the use of sandpaper during the South Africa series and even warned Bancroft to be careful. He also described an earlier incident during the second Test in Port Elizabeth where the players experimented with sandpaper on the ball. Khawaja argued that the episode should be seen as a collective failure rather than one where three players bore the brunt of the punishment.

His account drew a strong response from Australia captain Pat Cummins, who rejected suggestions that he and other members of the bowling group were aware of the plan. At a long press conference, Cummins described Khawaja’s claims as “complete and utter nonsense” and said there was no team plan or discussion involving the pitchers.

Cummins also questioned why Khawaja didn’t intervene when he knew what was going on, saying the former opener’s account was vague and that he knew about the talks involving Bancroft did not mean the entire dressing room knew about the plan.

However, Warner backed Khawaja and criticized Cummins for his response. The former Australian opener said he was disappointed the captain had thrown Khawaja “under the bus” and reiterated his belief Cricket Australia’s original investigation was rushed and botched. Warner claimed that Khawaja, who was sitting next to Bancroft during the earlier incident, was not interviewed as part of the investigation.

The conflicting accounts turned attention back to the original investigation, which found that Smith, Warner and Bancroft were involved in a ball-tampering scheme. Smith and Warner received 12-month bans, while Bancroft was suspended for nine months. Khawaja was not questioned during the investigation.

THIS IS NOT A RE-INVESTIGATION: GREENBERG

CA chief executive Todd Greenberg acknowledged the recent revelations revealed starkly different memories of the incident and said the governing body needed to recognize its own role in the culture that existed in Australian cricket at the time.

“What happened then and is still happening now has a lot to do with the culture that existed at the time. The culture that CA played a role in creating,” Greenberg said.

He pointed to the Ethics Center report commissioned after the scandal and the subsequent acceptance of 36 of its 42 recommendations as part of changes made to Australian cricket.

Greenberg said the forum was an opportunity to give all parties a chance to express themselves in an independent, safe and private environment, but he was clear about its limitations.

“This is not a re-investigation, it is not intended to re-prosecute or sanction. No one is forced to participate – it is entirely up to them individually,” he said.

“Let’s be honest – the game is hurting right now. It’s not good for anybody. We have to find a way and we have to heal.”

Boon also urged those involved and the wider cricket community to allow the process to unfold in private, expressing hope that it would help restore relations strained by the scandal.

– The end