No evidence from ECI to prove SIR was ‘unanimous’ decision, Rahul Gandhi to Supreme Court

Leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi on Monday (Nov 16, 2026) told the Supreme Court that the Election Commission of India (ECI) has not produced any evidence to substantiate its claim that the Special Intensive Review (SIR) was a “unanimous” decision by Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Vianesh Kumar and Election Commissioners Jókhbir Sandhushi Sukhvek.

“With ECI’s counter affidavit dated October 26, no meeting minutes, file entries, recorded approvals, agenda, proceedings or other primary material was produced to prove the participation and consent of all the three members,” Mr Gandhi said in his rejoinder.

Interrogatories filed

Mr. Gandhi and other leaders of the INDIA bloc also separately filed an application containing a set of “interrogatories” targeting the CEC, the two Election Commissioners and other senior ECI officials involved in the SIR. The issues at stake relate to the number and details of each SIR file as well as the specific occasions between 19 February 2025 and 26 October 2026 on which the two Electoral Commissioners objected in writing or expressed disagreement or reservations on any matter relating to the SIR, ECINET, Form 6 or the filing of an appeal.

The case is scheduled to be heard on November 17 before a bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant.

Reported friction between Mr. Kumar and the two election commissioners over the SIR and the CEC’s alleged one-sided and authoritarian behavior sparked widespread protests across India demanding his removal from office.

The ECI’s October 26 affidavit in response to a petition filed by the leaders of the INDIA bloc headed by Mr. Gandhi denied any difference of opinion between the CEC and the Election Commissioners regarding the SIR process.

Mr. Gandhi said the court must not accept such “bare claims” by the ECI. He questioned why the affidavit was filed with the ECI when Mr. Kumar, Mr. Sandhu and Mr. Joshi were separately as respondents.

The Leader of the Opposition, represented by senior advocate AM Singhvi and advocate Prasanna S, said the EC had chosen not to explain when and where exactly the decision to conduct a state-wide SIR was taken.

The empty claims in the ECI affidavit are contradicted by its own Right to Information (RTI) reply that “The Commission has not yet taken any decision to initiate Special Intensive Review (SIR) across the country in 2025”.

Mr. Gandhi said that the ECI’s claim of a “unanimous” commission was completely belied by the fact that Mr. Sandhu and Mr. Joshi took the unprecedented step of writing directly to the Cabinet Secretary expressing their displeasure with the conduct of affairs within the electoral body during the SIR exercise.

“That two members of the Commission felt it necessary to approach the Cabinet Secretary and issue their own joint direction, itself defies the image of unanimous functioning,” the LoP said, adding that their communications could not be dismissed as “internal differences or administrative exchanges”.

Issue of form 6

Mr Gandhi questioned the logic of the EC’s contention that the additional declaration form attached to the statutory Form 6 was separate and “not part of Form 6”.

He pointed out that the declaration “was entered on the online page of Form 6” and that the online application and the declaration were combined for one OTP and e-signature.

“The applicant accessing the online Form 6 must have come across an additional statement as part of this process and filled it in,” argued his rejoinder.

He highlighted the statements made by the ECI in its October 26 affidavit that more than 16 lakh appeals against the inclusion of voters in West Bengal were filed by officials of the state’s Chief Electoral Office, that too without consulting the electoral body.

“This corroborates the very complaint alleged to have been raised by the Election Commissioners, namely that the appeals were filed on behalf of the Commission without the knowledge of its members,” Mr. Gandhi alleged.

If not, the ECI must record appropriate approvals for filing such appeals against inclusion in the electoral roll of West Bengal.

Opaque ECI platforms

The LoP said the ECI’s explanation on ECINET and ERONET, digital platforms managing voter registration and voter lists, did not address the specific concerns raised in the court about their design, configuration, operation and control.

The petitioners argued that the functioning of the ECINET and ERONET systems was both centralized and opaque, leading to widespread voter exclusion.

Mr. Gandhi urged the court to take note of the ECI’s “complete silence” on several issues such as the reduction of around 20.66 million names from the electoral roll in Punjab and around 12.8 million voters, non-availability of orders and guidelines governing the intensive 2003 revision, including in the mass mapping of alleged electoral premises. names and analysis indicating that women constituted approximately 62% of excluded voters in West Bengal.

“The present proceedings cannot be terminated on the basis of blanket denials or subsequent explanations and demonstration of woefully belated course corrections,” Mr. Gandhi asked the court.

Published – 16 Nov 2026 17:55 IST