What did India learn from facing football’s big boys in FIFA qualifiers?

“Why do we fall? To learn to get back up.”

Thomas Wayne’s words in Batman Begins might be worth remembering for Indian football.

The Blue Tigers have fallen repeatedly in their last five international matches against Brazil, Uruguay, Panama and New Zealand. No one expected them to take victory against these opponents. But they were expected to pick up a few lessons along the way. Instead, the same questions keep cropping up on Khalid Jamil’s side.

Five friendly matches, four defeats, one draw and 19 conceded goals. India got the chance to rub shoulders with some of the best in international football, but what did they actually take away from these encounters? If you keep facing stronger opponents without showing that you can adapt, improve or even change the script, what exactly is the point?

But the bigger question is whether India should have sacrificed competitive tournament football in the first place to make room for these glamorous fixtures. The AIFF chose Brazil before the FIFA ASEAN Cup, then it was difficult senior team commitments in New Zealand alongside the SAFF Championship.

And after all that juggling, the promised lessons of playing the big boys are still hard to uncover.

BRAZILIAN NIGHT WORTH THE COST

Let’s go back a bit.

When Brazil’s visit to Kolkata was announced, Indian football had every reason to celebrate. Watching Vinicius Junior and company take on the Blue Tigers at Salt Lake Stadium was a once-in-a-generation opportunity for many fans. The AIFF also understandably wanted it to happen.

But like all good things come at a price, so does this.

India have already been invited to participate in the inaugural FIFA ASEAN Cup, where they were scheduled to face Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore. The competition offered three guaranteed competitive matches against teams that India could realistically face in future Asian competitions and qualification campaigns.

A friendly with Brazil, scheduled for 3 October, clashed with the ASEAN Cup final on 4 October. The AIFF initially explored the possibility of sending separate teams, but eventually withdrew from the tournament after FIFA’s participation requirements made that option unfeasible.

AIFF general secretary M Satyanarayan was quite frank in saying that India regularly face ASEAN opposition and can play these teams again, while the opportunity to host Brazil may not arise again.

Brazil was Brazil after all. But former Indian captain Bhaichung Bhutia had a different opinion. He argued that three or four competitive matches would be more beneficial to the team’s development than a one-off glamor friendly.

But can we ignore the obvious?

The ASEAN Cup was not Brazil. It didn’t have the same star power or commercial appeal. But it offered something India desperately needed, competitive minutes against teams closer to their level, where they could build combinations, experiment and, importantly, compete for results.

The AIFF picked up the spectacle and promised to make up for the lost tournament exposure with more high-profile friendlies.

The question now is whether this trade-off has paid off.

SAME SCENARIO, DIFFERENT OPPONENTS

India’s September-October international window has begun and 1-1 draw against Panama in Bengaluru. There were encouraging passages of play and the Blue Tigers showed that they can threaten even a higher-ranked opponent.

Then came Brazil.

In the opening 25 minutes at the Salt Lake Stadium, India really made the visitors work. The back line pushed high, the players looked willing to take responsibility for the ball and Brazil were repeatedly caught offside by India. Sahal Abdul Samad looked comfortable receiving the ball under pressure, while Ryan Williams provided an outlet on the wing.

It wasn’t dominance, and it probably never will be. But India were making Brazil uncomfortable and there was plenty of evidence that this could turn into a real contest.

After that, Brazil changed the angle of the game.

As Estevao became increasingly influential, Brazil found ways around India’s defensive structure and the opening goal came in the 28th minute. Once the initial resistance was broken, the gap between the two sides became more and more apparent.

India ended up losing 4-0. Individual errors, including a difficult night for Gurpreet Singh Sandhu, made matters worse. Jamil admitted after the match that lapses in concentration and individual mistakes cost his side dearly. He also emphasized that India needed to play more matches of this quality to gain experience.

Fairly. But Uruguay’s game three days later suggested the lessons didn’t travel very far.

India lost 6-1 with Anirudh Thapa scoring a historic score but an insignificant goal. Uruguay regained control and India struggled to keep up.

A pattern emerged. India could compete in short bursts, but sustaining that intensity against stronger opponents proved to be a different challenge altogether.

Against both Brazil and Uruguay, the Blue Tigers looked increasingly out of gas after the opening 30 minutes. The players tried to keep their form, the distances between them increased and it was easier to dictate the actions of the opponent.

Interestingly, there were brief signs of life after Jamil made several substitutions deep into the second half of both games. Fresh legs brought back some of the energy and urgency that India had shown early on. But these explosions were short-lived and by then the damage was largely done.

Was it a fitness issue? Has India struggled to maintain the intensity of its approach? These were the questions that needed to be answered before the next international assignment.

Instead, the New Zealand tour brought more of the same.

FIVE GAMES, SAME OLD QUESTIONS

The two matches against New Zealand should have been an opportunity for India to apply what they had learned from the September-October period. Instead, the Blue Tigers were beaten 5-0 in Auckland and 3-0 in Christchurch.

The first defeat was particularly disappointing. India struggled to keep possession, were repeatedly exposed to New Zealand’s movement and conceded five goals. Hosts didn’t have to do anything extraordinary to find seats.

After a 5-0 defeat, one would have expected a more convincing answer. Jamil made five changes for the second match in Christchurch and changed the team’s form, but India conceded three more times before half-time.

The hosts were in control for most of the match and India struggled to create something meaningful at the other end. The second half was better in terms of scoring, but it was hardly a response to suggest the team had turned a corner.

It’s not about waiting for Jamil to find the magic formula in a few weeks. Nor is it about questioning every pick or rotation after a defeat. But with five games showing the same weaknesses, the coaching staff must offer more than another reminder that the opposition has been stronger.

India needed to show some scholarship. Instead, the team still looked like they were dealing with the same issues for the first time.

WHAT ABOUT THE SAFF CHAMPIONSHIP?

That’s the burning question we all come to.

The SAFF Championship was originally scheduled for 21 September to 6 October, but was pushed back to 4 to 17 November after India’s interest in participating in the inaugural FIFA ASEAN Cup prompted a change in the calendar of the regional tournament.

India eventually withdrew from the ASEAN Cup in favor of a friendly with Brazil. Then, with the New Zealand tour scheduled for 12 and 15 November, senior team commitments again collided with the knockout stages of the SAFF Championship.

For a while, there was real uncertainty as to whether India would even participate in the regional tournament. Reports suggested the defending champions could pull out due to squad formation difficulties. The SAFF eventually dismissed the speculation and clarified that it had not received any official communication from the AIFF regarding India’s withdrawal.

India ended up sending a mostly under-23 team under Naushad Moosa, while Jamil’s senior team traveled to New Zealand.

The tournament started outside FIFA’s international window, meaning clubs were not required to release their players for the opening matches. The team was subsequently reshuffled, with Bijoy Varghese, Muhammad Suhail and Liston Colaco being called up to the senior side for the tour of New Zealand.

Farukh Choudhary, Noufal PN and Hmingthanmawia Ralte were also released to return to Mumbai City FC, while injuries further limited Moosa’s options.

Meanwhile, the under-23 side continued. India defeated Pakistan 3–2 in the group stage and defeated Bhutan 2–1 in the semi-finals to reach the final.

According to a Khel Now report, Moosa will have only 17 fielders available for the final against Pakistan, with no further reinforcements planned.

Pakistan, on the other hand, strengthened its squad with the arrival of diaspora players before the semi-final, where they beat home Bangladesh 1-0.

A depleted team isn’t the main story here, but it’s a prime example of what happens when competing commitments aren’t properly managed. Moosa’s young side had to go through the tournament with a changing group of players, while the senior team returned from New Zealand without a win.

and for what?

WHAT WAS THE PURPOSE OF THE FIVE FRIENDSHIPS?

There is absolutely nothing wrong with finding stronger opposition. Indian football needs more such opportunities. Playing against teams with greater technical prowess, physicality and international experience can expose weaknesses not always seen against regional opponents.

But exposure alone does not guarantee development.

The ASEAN Cup offered India competitive matches against teams closer to their level. The SAFF Championship offered an opportunity to defend the title and provide the younger players with meaningful tournament experience. Both contests had their own merits, and neither should be considered expendable simply because a glamorous matchup appeared.

The argument is not that India should stop playing Brazil, Uruguay or New Zealand. Quite the opposite. The Blue Tigers should play more teams of this quality. But those matches must fit into a larger development plan, not become a substitute for competitive football.

And the coaching staff needs to be able to show what they learned from them.

There have been some changes in approach, but there is not enough evidence that the team is still better equipped to handle the challenges these devices were supposed to pose.

The AIFF also needs to think beyond the appeal of a big-name opponent. A friendly with Brazil may fill the stadium and generate huge excitement, but three competitive matches against Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore could offer something that one glamor match simply cannot replicate.

There is no guarantee that India will win the ASEAN Cup or defend the SAFF title with a senior team. But at least those contests would give the team a chance to build rhythm, test combinations, and compete for something tangible.

India got the accessories they wanted. They got the exposure they were promised. It remains unclear whether they have improved.

Because there’s no point sitting at the big boy table when you’re going to leave without learning how to play the game.

– The end