The lawyer made the derogatory remarks in the court against the CJI
This cautious attitude may have resulted from past instances of chaotic disruptions during verbal mentions. File | Photo credit: The Hindu
A lawyer was escorted out of the courtroom of the Chief Justice of India after he made disparaging remarks directed at Chief Justice Surya Kant on Monday (November 16, 2026).
The incident occurred shortly after Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana convened at 2 p.m.
Chief Justice Kant did not preside over his bench in the morning and joined after lunch. He was on an official tour in Brazil during the latter part of the Deepavali holiday. November 16 was the first working day for the court after the festival holiday. The Judicial Circular informed that the Bench will begin by hearing oral arguments for early listing of cases, followed by matters requiring a three-judge combination.
The lawyer in question first apologized to Justices Bagchi and Mohan, saying that he had filed the petition for the “favorable judgment of Justice Surya Kant”.
“This item was handed over to Justice Surya Kant 15 days ago in his office on November 2, so I am compelled to appear before this court…” he said.
Justice Mohan intervened to warn the lawyer that he could not mention such matters in court. But the lawyer insisted. “I can. It’s urgent. I apologized first,” he said.
The president of the court said that the court will deal with the case. “Please wait,” the CJI addressed him.
The lawyer replied that he would not wait. He made a derogatory comment about the Chief Justice’s “integrity”. The audio-video transmission was suspended immediately after these remarks.
Subsequently, lawyers present in the courtroom said that the lawyer in question was involved in a contempt case. Other lawyers in the courtroom, including members of the bar, hit out at such unsavory remarks against the CJI in a public hearing. The man was eventually brought out.
In the recent past, the oral references in the CJI’s court have been expunged.
Oral arguments are a common routine that is usually witnessed once the court is assembled. Lawyers are heard making urgent requests for hearings, sometimes to protect life, liberty and other fundamental rights. It is a unique window for lawyers and litigants that directly catches the attention of the Chief Justice of India.
Recently, the court has expressed growing concern that petitioners have personally attempted to deliberately assault judges in open courtrooms in full view of cameras and later embarrass the judiciary and the institution by using illegally uploaded images online.
What started with the CJI deleting the oral submissions of the complainants in person has gradually become a total silencing of the oral submissions, whether made by the petitioner or counsel. The fodder would resume only after the formal hearing of the said cases for that day has commenced.
This cautious attitude may have resulted from past instances of chaotic disruptions during verbal mentions.
Chief Justice Kant’s immediate predecessor, Justice BR Gavai, had to face a rude and unrepentant lawyer who hurled an object at his bench, while the Vacation Bench headed by Justice KV Viswanathan suffered some tense moments when another lawyer threw wads of paper in the air.
Published – 16 Nov 2026 10:00 PM IST