India must balance energy needs with climate adaptation, says US scientist | Today’s news

India should prioritize meeting its growing energy requirements and building climate resilience rather than pursuing rapid decarbonisation at the expense of economic development, Steven E. Koonin, a senior fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution, told the Hindustan Times Leadership Summit.

India’s immediate energy needs must take precedence over emissions reduction targets as the country continues to develop, the professor said, adding that access to reliable and affordable energy is essential to raising living standards, boosting industrial activity and building resilience to climate-related risks.

“India’s top priority must be to get the energy it needs to develop. You can worry about emissions secondarily,” he said in an interview, adding that the country must balance three pillars of energy policy: availability, reliability and decarbonization.

His remarks come as India continues to rely on coal to meet electricity demand, even as the country expands renewable energy capacity and pursues long-term decarbonisation goals.

Developing economies require more energy as they grow, Koonin said, pointing to low air-conditioning penetration in India as a sign of unmet energy demand. Only 15% of Indian households own air conditioning, the professor noted, stressing that expanding access to electricity must remain a priority as incomes rise.

“Energy needs are immediate; they are solvable, while the climate threat is distant, vague and uncertain,” he said.

While Koonin acknowledged that human activities affect the climate, he questioned the scale of projected impacts, arguing that climate debates often overestimate future risks while paying too little attention to the economic and technological limits to reducing emissions. Widely seen as a climate skeptic, Koonin worked as chief scientist before serving at the US Department of Energy, or DoE, in Barack Obama’s first administration. He came to prominence with his 2021 book Unsettled: What Climate Science Tells Us, What It Doesn’t, and Why It Matters.

“Nuclear Power Key to India’s Future”

Describing nuclear power as a vital part of India’s future energy mix, the professor said the country needs reliable sources of electricity to sustain economic expansion.

“I think nuclear energy has to be a big part of India’s future,” he said, adding that greater investment in climate science, improved forecasting models and adaptation measures should also remain a priority.

Economic growth alone will help India build resilience to climate challenges, Koonin said, as better infrastructure, stronger public services and wider access to energy improve its ability to handle extreme weather. Countries should also focus on developing technologies with lower emissions that do not cost more than conventional coal power, he added.

The expansion of renewable energy has not yet substantially reduced dependence on fossil fuels, the professor noted. Coal, oil and natural gas still account for around 80% of global primary energy consumption, with renewables contributing to overall energy supply rather than replacing conventional fuels.

Read also | No time to waste: Climate finance is the main topic of the COP31 summit

“Nuclear Power Key to India’s Future”

Describing nuclear power as a vital part of India’s future energy mix, the professor said the country needs reliable sources of electricity to sustain economic expansion.

“I think nuclear energy has to be a big part of India’s future,” he said, adding that greater investment in climate science, improved forecasting models and adaptation measures should also remain a priority.

Economic growth alone will help India build resilience to climate challenges, Koonin said, as better infrastructure, stronger public services and wider access to energy improve its ability to handle extreme weather. Countries should also focus on developing technologies with lower emissions that do not cost more than conventional coal power, he added.

The expansion of renewable energy has not yet substantially reduced dependence on fossil fuels, the professor noted. Coal, oil and natural gas still account for around 80% of global primary energy consumption, with renewables contributing to overall energy supply rather than replacing conventional fuels.

Read also | Why India’s steel ambitions require a clear climate transition plan

Long-term climate trends in India

Citing data from the India Meteorological Department (IMD), Koonin said India’s average temperature has risen by about 0.68 degrees Celsius over the past century — significantly less than the average warming seen on global landmasses. On the monsoon, the professor noted that long-term rainfall data shows no significant downward trend, despite wide variations over decades.

He also pointed to changes in northwest India’s Thar Desert, noting that the region has become wetter and greener over the past two decades, along with an increase in agricultural productivity. Regarding extreme weather, Koonin said that tropical cyclones are not becoming more frequent over the long term, nor is there a clear upward trend in the number of deaths related to extreme temperatures in India.

Citing IMD figures, the professor noted 35 heatwave-related deaths in the previous year, admitting that some observers believe official figures underestimate such deaths. India’s agricultural output has also increased in the past two decades despite warmer temperatures, he said, adding that climate change has had no detectable impact on the country’s overall economic growth. According to Press Information Bureau reports, total foodgrain production in India is estimated at 376.56 million tonnes in 2025–26 (third advance estimates), up from 265.05 million tonnes in 2013–14.

About climate change

While human activity has affected the climate, Koonin said the current data does not reflect the dramatic shifts often reported. In 2025, during Donald Trump’s second presidency, Koonin co-authored a DoE report, A Critical Review of Impacts of Greenhouse Gas Emissions on the US Climate, which questioned the scientific conclusions about greenhouse gas emissions causing climate change.

“The question is how the climate responds to human influences – will we see more storms, faster sea level rise? The data doesn’t show that,” the professor said, adding that the globe has warmed by 1.3 degrees Celsius and is expected to warm by a similar amount in the next century.

“What gives me hope for the future is that the globe has warmed 1.3 degrees Celsius since 1900 and is projected to warm by the same amount in the next century. In the last 120 years, as the global temperature has risen, the population has grown, life expectancy has increased to 70 years, GDP per capita has increased by a factor of 7,” he said, adding that literacy has increased due to extreme weather, as well as mortality. Koonin reiterated his view on the Indian monsoon, adding: “You can see the ups and downs that happen over many decades, but it’s hard to see a trend over the long term.”

Climate change vs local environmental issues

Addressing Delhi’s ongoing air pollution crisis, the professor said local pollution and carbon dioxide emissions are distinct problems requiring different policy responses. Local air quality can be addressed through regulation and cleaner technologies, he said, citing Los Angeles as a city that has cleaned up its air despite population growth. On climate science, Koonin called for stronger monitoring systems, better forecasting models and deeper research into regional climate patterns.

The professor also touched on geoengineering – specifically solar radiation management, which involves reflecting a fraction of sunlight back into space to reduce global temperatures – warning that the method carries high risks and could disrupt rainfall patterns.

Ultimately, India should focus on economic growth, broader energy access and climate adaptation while exploring available low-emission technologies, rather than allowing decarbonisation goals to hamper its immediate development needs, Koonin concluded.

Read also | India’s carbon market: Why it will need wider support systems

Similar Posts