Sandpapergate reopened: Australian cricket has an Odyssey problem

Odysseus returned from the Trojan War a hero. Homer celebrated the story of a cunning man who found his way into the seemingly impregnable city of Troy and led the Greeks to victory in a move so swift that no one at the time could have imagined it.

In Homer’s account, trickery was part of Odysseus’ cunning. However, the sadness that could have resulted from his actions did not seem to weigh him down.

So when Odysseus returned to his island, many years after the war, indirectly participating in the slaughter of his men and cheating on his wife (he spent his years with the goddess and nymph Calypso), he was still celebrated.

Homer wrote his version of the story in the 8th century BC.

Christopher Nolan reimagines the story very differently in his 2026 film The Odyssey.

Odysseus here is troubled by his actions, the part he played in the deaths of his men, and is filled with sorrow as he returns to his wife and his only son.

This is not my reading of two versions of the story, but one borrowed from a lovely interview with Nolan by political theorist Yiyang Zhuge.

SABR IS CREATING A RISE

I bring this up because this view of a past event made me take note The Sandpapergate controversy that burst into the limelight this week, courtesy of Usman Khawaj’s book.

For a book called Sabrwhich means patience in Urdu, has created quite a stir in world cricket and beyond.

Captain of Australia Pat Cummins took it upon himself to comment on the controversy at a press conference on the day of Australia’s match against England. Cummins was not part of the playing squad at Optus Stadium in Perth but spoke to reporters in Sydney.

Cummins denied allegations that the entire Australian team, including support staff, knew about the incident. He said there was no master plan in which everyone agreed to use a foreign agent, in this case sandpaper, on the ball.

Cummins denied ‘master plan’ to use sandpaper sometime in 2018 #cricket #PatCummins #Sandpaper #UsmanKhawaja Prime Video Sport AUNZ (@pvsportaunz) November 13, 2026

It didn’t help that this whole saga had already been reopened during Australia’s tour of South Africa before it erupted during their ODI series against England.

Of course it caught fire. Now, what some people have suggested, and what many others have at least thought, is that this case needs to be reopened.

SANDPAPER REVISITED

But there is a problem. An Odyssey-sized problem: we’re looking for blame in the locker room instead of the boardroom.

During Sandpapergate in 2018, the ICC banned Steve Smith for one match and paid 100 percent of his match fee. Youngster Cameron Bancroft was given three demerit points as well as a financial penalty.

Australian cricket was seen as a tyrant at the time. They have just come off a hot Test series against India in 2017. The National Board and its players have also been embroiled in a major money dispute.

As vice-captain, David Warner became the most outspoken public face of the players’ fight for their rights. He publicly criticized Cricket Australia administrators for continuing to draw their salaries while around 230 players remained unpaid after their contracts expired on 30 June 2017. He even warned that Australia may not have a squad for the 2017-18 Ashes series if the players’ revenue-sharing rights are taken away.

When Sandpapergate happened, Cricket Australia may have seen an opportunity.

CA handed out 12-month bans from international and domestic cricket to both Warner and Smith. As a result, Warner was left out of the 2018–19 national contract list, banned from the 2018 Indian Premier League, costing him a Rs 12 crore contract, and dropped by major personal sponsors.

Since then, Australia have actively sought to be the nice boys of world cricket.

This is where a bigger exercise was played. Australian cricket struggled to change the way it was perceived, both inside and outside the dressing room. And Sandpapergate gave Cricket Australia an opportunity to draw a line between its past and the future it wanted to sell.

They brought in Pat Cummins as captain who prided himself on inclusiveness. Australia has once again become a force in international cricket, but this time without the profanity.

Sandpapergate also brought technological and broadcasting changes. The noise on the pitch that we so often hear during international matches was a direct result of the scandal.

And now, in 2026, with the wounds reopened, Usman Khawaja says there is more to it than meets the eye. He says three cricketers fell when the entire team should have been held accountable.

From my point of view, the punishment given in 2018 was strange. It made Australian cricket better, which was what was needed, wasn’t it? That was the goal of the whole exercise.

As of 2018, Australia are proud of their practices, how they have given voice to the Indigenous community and how they have moved away from the poor methods and culture that once existed in their dressing room.

NOLAN’S GRINDING GATE

The reopening of Sandpapergate should not mean putting Steve Smith, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft on trial again. They were punished for their actions in 2018. It is not about their guilt this time. If anything, the new allegations should make us look at the episode through a different lens.

What role did Cricket Australia and its administrators play in the whole episode? Was the investigation as thorough as it should have been? Were the penalties given purely as a cricketing decision, or did the management also see an opportunity to make an example of their senior players and distance themselves from a culture that had become an obstacle?

These are questions for the boardroom, not another round of scrutiny for the locker room.

Consider what happened this week. Pat Cummins, who was not even part of Australia’s squad for the ODI series against England, made himself available to the media in Sydney. He was willing to face questions about the episode, which took place eight years ago, and insists he knew nothing about it. He spent over an hour addressing the allegations in Usman Khawaja’s book.

Cummins was categorical in his denial. He called Khawaja’s suggestion that he and others helped devise the ball-tampering plan “complete and utter nonsense”. He also defended Cricket Australia’s original investigation, saying he was questioned at the time and answered everything fairly.

Here’s something worth considering. If the captain of the Australian team is ready to face the media and answer questions about the episode that continues to follow him, why is Cricket Australia so reluctant to return to it?

general manager Todd Greenberg has already made his position clear. In an interview with SEN, he said there were specific details in Khawaja’s book that contradicted statements given by other members of the 2018 squad. Still, he claimed Cricket Australia was satisfied with the outcome of its investigation and saw no “compelling reason” to reopen it. “I don’t think there’s anything to be gained from it,” he said.

That’s exactly where the problem lies.

If the allegations are that the original investigation was rushed, botched or deliberately limited to a handful of players, surely the onus is on Cricket Australia to demonstrate that this was not the case. David Warner publicly supported Khawaja’s account and questioned the integrity of the original investigation. Khawaja, meanwhile, said he was never interviewed by Cricket Australia despite being present in the dressing room during the Cape Town Test.

These are not questions that can be dismissed just because eight years have passed.

And while Cricket Australia believes there is no point in conducting a new investigation, it can do something else. It can make publicly available the findings of its original investigation, its scope, the people it interviewed and the basis on which it reached its conclusions. If the full report has not been issued, there is no reason why the Board cannot now publish a comprehensive account with relevant adjustments if necessary.

Transparency does not automatically mean reopening the case or overturning penalties. It means allowing the public to understand how the institution arrived at a decision that fundamentally changed the careers of three international cricketers. If Cricket Australia is confident that its investigation was fair and thorough, the publication of its findings should only strengthen that position.

There is also the larger issue of liability. In 2018, Cricket Australia had an opportunity to draw a line between a culture that devalued the game and a culture it wanted to build. It did so quite emphatically through punishing Smith, Warner and Bancroft. The Board subsequently rebuilt its image and Australian cricket found a new identity under Cummins.

However, institutions cannot claim credit for the transformation and refuse to answer questions about the methods by which this transformation was achieved.

Homer’s Odysseus returned home a hero. Nolan’s Odysseus returned with the weight of everything he did to get there.

Three cricketers spent eight years living with the aftermath of Sandpapergate. Cricket Australia, meanwhile, had to rebuild its image on its back.

Maybe it’s time we stopped examining only the men who held the sandpaper and started questioning the institution that held the hammer.

– The end