PT Usha faces eligibility questions on ice hockey nomination ahead of IOA elections

Controversy surrounding the Indian Olympic Association (IOA) elections took another turn on December 5, with a formal objection raised against President PT Usha’s nomination as the Ice Hockey Association of India (IHAI) representative. The challenge centers on whether Usha meets the constitutional requirement to represent a national sports federation of which he is said not to be a member.

Supreme Court advocate Atul Kumar filed a challenge to Electoral Officer Sanjay Kumar Srivastava on November 13 to verify Usha’s eligibility under Article 10.4 of the IOA Constitution 2026. The provision states that representatives nominated by National Sports Federations (NSFs) must be members of the relevant bodies.

This development comes after Usha failed to secure a place in the Sportsmen of Exceptional Merit (SOM) election. In the women’s category, she finished fifth with 40 votes behind Anju Bobby George (53), Rani Rampal (50), Dola Banerjee (45) and Saina Nehwal (43). Since only the top four candidates qualified, the IOA President lost his seat on the General Body through the SOM.

Her name subsequently appeared in the provisional Electoral College as the IHAI representative alongside Harjinder Singh. The nomination offered Usha another possible route to the general body and kept her election prospects alive. However, questions about its membership and the federation’s nominating authority now put the trip under scrutiny.

The latest objection adds to the series of controversies surrounding the IOA elections. Olympic champion Abhinav Bindra questioned the clarity of SOM election rules, while the former sprinter Ashwini Nachappa alleged that the candidates were forced to resign from the process. The call for Usha’s nomination has now brought into focus the eligibility of the representatives of the electorate.

USHA ICE HOCKEY MEMBERSHIP QUESTION

Kumar asked the election officer to find out whether Usha is a registered member of IHAI and if so, in which category she was admitted. His representation requests the verification of its membership application, the date of approval, the original list of members of the federation and the constitutional provisions governing its introduction.

The objection also questions the validity of the EC-1 form submitted in support of the nomination. Kumar asked for verification of signatures, authorizations and resolutions on the basis of which Usha was selected as representative. He asked that her nomination not be considered final until the relevant records are reviewed. If the requirement for mandatory membership is not established, he requested her removal from the final electoral college.

IHAI’S RIVAL FACTIONS JOIN LINE

The challenge has become complicated because the Indian ice hockey administration is itself embroiled in a controversy. The Kunzang Namgyal-led faction separately protested against the nomination of Usha and Harjinder Singh, saying that the leadership that submitted their names did not have a valid mandate.

In a letter to the election officer, Ajit Kakkar, who identifies himself as the vice-president of the Namgyal-led faction, claimed that Usha is not a member of IHAI.

“It is pertinent to note that Ms. PT Usha is not a member of the Ice Hockey Association of India and yet she has been nominated as one of the delegates, thereby falsely implying that she is a member of the nominating federation,” the letter said.

Kakkar also questioned the authority of IHAI president Gurpreet Singh Bakshi and general secretary Harjinder Singh, saying their tenure and mandate should be fixed. His faction has claimed that it has the legitimate authority to govern the sport after elections held on 2 August 2026. However, the Ministry of Sports does not recognize any national governing body for ice hockey, with rival factions continuing to fight for control of the federation.

IOC EXPRESSES CONCERN ABOUT IOA DISPUTES

The controversy also reached the International Olympic Committee (IOC). Sports administrator KP Rao approached the international body, seeking intervention in the IOA election process and seeking the appointment of an observer to oversee the polls.

The IOC expressed disappointment at the development, terming the situation extremely regrettable and saying it once again affects the functioning and reputation of the Olympic movement in India. She called on those responsible for the conduct of the elections to ensure full compliance with the Olympic Charter.

In a separate representation, Kumar sought the release of a forensic audit of the IOA’s accounts covering the period from 2019 to 2022. He claimed that although the audit was completed, its findings were not presented to the Executive Council or the General Assembly. He requested that the full report be scrutinized and any findings forwarded to the IOA Ethics Committee prior to the nomination review process.

The statement raises questions about the audit procedure but does not find financial wrongdoing by any individual.

Before the final voter list is published, the election officer is scheduled to investigate and handle the objections. With the December 5 polls looming, the controversy over Usha’s nomination has become another flashpoint in an election process that has faced growing questions over eligibility, transparency and governance in Indian sports.

– The end